1History of Migraine Surgery
Bahman Guyuron
Salient Points
• Scalding of the forehead in an attempt to treat frontal migraine headaches (MHs) during the 10th century is the first ablative measure.
• Surgical attempts to mitigate MHs date back to 1923 when Jonnesco first removed the stellate ganglion.
• Walter Dandy removed the inferior cervical and first thoracic sympathetic ganglions in two patients in 1931. Dickerson described success with ligation of middle meningeal artery in 1932.
• In 1946, Rowbotham reported success with operation in three cases obtained by periarterial sympathectomy at the carotid bifurcation and excision of the superior cervical ganglion combined with ligation of the external carotid artery.
• Resection of the greater superficial petrosal nerve for the treatment of various types of unilateral headaches was suggested by Gardner et al in 1946.
• Total resection of the trigeminal nerve within the cranial base (trigeminal neurectomy) has also been tested. However, the morbidity was prohibitive.
• Murillo, in 1968, suggested removal of the temporal neurovascular bundle for treatment of MHs.
• An occipital neurectomy was suggested for patients with occipital MHs and neuritis by Murphy in 1969.
• In 1992, Maxwell reported trigeminal ganglio-rhizolysis for treatment of MHs in eight male patients through percutaneous radiofrequency.
• A retrospective study to validate the observation by patients that their headaches had disappeared after a forehead lift was completed in 2000 by Guyuron.
• The first prospective pilot study to demonstrate the role of supraorbital and supratrochlear trigger site deactivation was published by Guyuron in 2002.
• The role of single site botulinum toxin injection was report by Behmand and Guyuron in 2003.
• Dirnberger confirmed Guyuron’s findings with a prospective study in 2004.
• The first randomized prospective study in surgical treatment of MHs was published in 2005 by Guyuron et al.
• Poggi also confirmed Guyuron’s findings in 2008.
• The first prospective randomized migraine surgery study including sham surgery was reported in 2009 by Guyuron et al.
• The long-term efficacy of migraine surgery was documented by Guyuron’s team with a 5-year follow-up study in 2011.
• For the first time, Guyuron, through a collaborative effort between three departments and using proteomic analysis and electron microscopy, demonstrated that patients who have MHs have myelin deficiency in 2014.
• The first retrospective study demonstrating the efficacy of surgical treatment in adolescent patients was completed in 2015.
1.1 Introduction
Failure of medical treatments to provide sufficient lasting and predicable relief for many patients has prompted investigators to search for a more successful solution for migraine headaches (MHs). Going back centuries ago, scalding of the frontal migraine site with a hot rod was promoted by the Andalusian-born physician Abulcasis, also called Abu El Qasim, in the 10th century. It is hard to imagine the excruciating pain and exceedingly disturbing scene related to such a primitive, drastic measure. The far-reaching nature of this approach, however, underscores the severity of the pain that migraine patients endure and how desperate they are to consent to undergo such an extreme procedure. This demonstrates one other salient fact. That is, even this far back in history, it was believed that by stopping the migraine trigger sites in the periphery one would control MH.
Surgical attempts to mitigate MH date back to 1923 when Jonnesco first removed the stellate ganglion and other parts of the sympathetic nervous system for treatment of MH. Dandy (1931), Penfield (1932), and Craig (1935) reported relief after excision of the stellate ganglion, while Love and Adson (1936) reported improvement in 12/16 patients with this technique.1