Epidemiology of Autoimmune Bullous Diseases



Fig. 21.1
Relative incidence of pemphigus vulgaris in different populations. The percentage of pemphigus vulgaris in relation to all pemphigus cases is shown




21.2.1 Incidence


The incidence of pemphigus considerably differs between different populations. It ranges from 0.6 to 0.76 per million per year in Switzerland and Finland to 8.0 and 10.0 in Greece and Iran [9, 2527]. The highest incidences, 16.1 and 32/million/year, were found in the Jewish population [28, 29] (Table 21.1) [8, 9, 11, 1319, 23, 2539]. The variability is most likely explained by different genetic backgrounds and trigger factors (see below). In addition, data quality of most epidemiological studies is hampered by their retrospective design and the inability to define the study populations, i.e., to ensure that all patients within a certain area are included. The latter shortcoming does not apply for three recent studies from Switzerland, the UK, and Taiwan that reported incidences of 0.6, 6.8, and 4.7/million/year, respectively [26, 37, 38]. Limitations of the latter studies, however, include the relatively low number of pemphigus patients in the Swiss study and the use of a general practitioner-based registry that may have included inadequately diagnosed patients in the UK population [26, 37, 40]. The Taiwanese National Health Insurance database has previously been the source of ample epidemiological studies. Pemphigus patients, however, were only studied after they had applied for a catastrophic illness certificate [38].


Table 21.1
Incidence of pemphigus





























































































































Region

Period

Incidence (million/year)

Israela [28]

1952–1972

16.1, Jewish

Connecticut, USAa [29]

1972–1977

4.2, non-Jewish

32, Jewish

Finland [25]

1969–1978

0.76

Francea [18, 30]

1985–1990

1.7

2002–2006

2.7

Malia [14]

Not defined

2.9

Malaysiaa [31]

Not defined

2.0 (PV only)

Tunisiaa [18, 32]

1985–1987

4.0

1986–1991

6.7

Bulgariaa [33]

1980–1995

4.7

Italya [15]

1982–1996

6.0

Saudi Arabiaa [16]

1990–1999

1.6

Indiaa [11]

2001

4.4

Serbiaa [23]

1990–2002

6.6

Kuwait

1991–2002

4.6

Germanya [34, 35]

1989–1997

0.98, entire population (PV only)

2001–2002

0.77, native Germans (PV only)

6.8, Southern Europeans (PV only)

0.6

Switzerland [26]

2001–2002

0.6

Irana [9, 13]

1991–2000

6.7

1984–2003

10.0

Turkeya [17, 36]

1998–2004

2.4

1998–2009

1.8

Macedonia [19]

1990–2004

4.4

Greecea [27]

1985–2004

8.0

UK [37]

1996–2006

6.8

Romaniaa [8]

2001–2007

4.0

Taiwan [38]

2002–2009

4.7

Croatiaa [39]

2005–2010

3.7


PV pemphigus vulgaris

aDefined region(s) of the country was (were) studied


21.2.2 Mortality


Mortality of PV and PF has been dramatically reduced by the use of corticosteroids in the early 1950s from 75 to 30 % [41]. The adjuvant use of immunosuppressants in the 1980s probably contributed to the further decrease in mortality to below 5 % of the study populations and 0.021 per 100,000 inhabitants of the USA [17, 41, 42]. In two recent studies from the UK and Taiwan, the risk of death was calculated to be two- to threefold higher compared to the control population [37, 38]. Infections, in particular pneumonia and septicemia, were the most frequent causes of death in different study populations [9, 38, 43]. Cardiovascular diseases and peptic ulcer disease were also significant reasons for death compared to the control population [38].


21.2.3 Associated Diseases


In two controlled studies an increased association of pemphigus was found with autoimmune thyroid disease and rheumatoid arthritis [44]. A case-control study revealed a higher incidence of autoimmune diseases in first-degree family members of PV patients [45]. A dramatically higher percentage of osteoporosis was diagnosed in pemphigus patients (40 %) compared to controls (6.5 %) [46] highlighting the importance of monitoring affected patients. This notion was reconfirmed in a controlled study in patients with immunobullous disorders, including pemphigus [47].



21.3 Endemic Pemphigus



21.3.1 Brazilian Pemphigus


Brazilian pemphigus, also called pemphigus braziliensis and fogo selvagem, occurs in some subtropical areas of Brazil, as well as in Northern Colombia. Data have been extensively collected in the Limao Verde Amerindian reservation in the state of Mato Grosso do Sul. Most patients affected by fogo selvagem are young adults and children, live in forest areas near rivers and streams, and are outdoor workers (farmers or their family members). The prevalence of the disease in this population is between 3 and 5 % [48]. There is no sex or racial predisposition. Most patients live in poor hygiene and housing conditions. The decreased prevalence of fogo selvagem in Sao Paulo and Parana was linked to improved living conditions [49, 50].


21.3.2 Columbian Pemphigus


The existence of other foci of endemic PF has been reported in the El Bagre area in Northern Columbia [51]. Patients affected with the disease also lived in rural areas. However, the majority of endemic PF patients are men (95 %). Similar to the braziliensis type, most patients with Columbian pemphigus are illiterate and poor and perform outdoor activities. The prevalence of the disease among the rural population is close to 5 % [52]. The significance of the presence of autoantibodies against the neural system and cardiac antigens in El Bagre PF patients remains unclear [53, 54].


21.3.3 Tunisian Pemphigus


Endemic Tunisian pemphigus mainly occurs in the southern area of Tunisia, in Algeria, Morocco, as well as in some sub-Saharan countries, such as Mali [14]. Overall, the incidence of Tunisian pemphigus is six to seven cases per million inhabitants per year. However, this incidence increases up to 20 cases per million inhabitants per year in some areas of South Tunisia, in particular in young adult women. Indeed, a predominance of cases among women aged 25–34 years has been described [32].


21.4 Paraneoplastic Pemphigus


Paraneoplastic pemphigus is very rare with about 300 reported cases in the literature [55, 56]. The disease is invariably associated with a neoplasm [57]. While in Chinese patients, Castleman’s disease is the predominate underlying neoplasm, in Europe, Japan, and the USA, non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma and chronic lymphocytic leukemia account for about two third of the neoplasms followed by Castleman’s disease, thymoma, and other diseases [5860]. The prognosis of paraneoplastic pemphigus is usually considered poor with a mortality rate ranging from 75 to 90 %. Its prognosis has been recently reevaluated in large series of 53 patients whose 1-, 2-, and 5-year overall survival rates were 49, 41, and 38 %, respectively [56]. Infections and evolution of the neoplasm were identified as the main cause of death with erythema multiforme-like skin lesions being associated with a twofold increased risk of death following multivariate analysis [56].


21.5 Bullous Pemphigoid



21.5.1 Incidence


Reported incidences of BP ranged between 2.4 and 23 new cases/million/year (Table 21.2) [8, 12, 26, 34, 37, 6168]. In a recent Swiss prospective study, an incidence of 12.1 new cases/1 million inhabitants/year was calculated [26]. This study is of particular importance since it encompassed the entire Swiss population. The Swiss data are in line with recent studies from Scotland and Germany with incidences of 14 and 13.4/million/year [34, 66]. A higher incidence of 23 new cases/ million/year has been recently estimated in France [62]. An even higher incidence of 66/million/year was reported in the UK based on a general practitioner database [37]. Interestingly, in Germany, France, and the UK, the incidence of BP has increased within the last 10 years (between twofold and 4.8-fold) [34, 37, 6163]. This may be due to either the increasing age of the population, the increased prevalence of debilitating neurological disorders (shown to be major risk factors for BP) [6971] (see below), and/or the increasing use of some drugs such as diuretics and psycholeptics. The latter have been also reported to be risk factors for BP in the elderly [69, 72]. An improved ability to diagnose BP and its atypical forms [62] is another explanation.


Table 21.2
Incidence of bullous pemphigoid







































































Region

Period

Incidence (million/year)

Francea

1984–1992

7.4 [61]

2000–2005

22 [62]

Germanya

1989–1994

6.7 [63]

2001–2002

13.4 [34]

Italya

1996–1997

10.0 [64]

Singapore

1998–1999

7.6 [65]

Scotlanda

1991–2001

14.0 [66]

Switzerland

2001–2002

12.1 [26]

Kuwait

1991–2005

2.6 [12]

Polanda

2000–2006

4.5 [67]

UK

1996–1998

13

1999–2001

37

2002–2004

59

2005–2006

66 [37]

Romaniaa

2001–2007

2.5 [8]

Guadeloupe

2006–2007

23 [68]


aDefined region(s) of the country was (were) studied

BP is a disease of the elderly with a mean age of disease between the ages of 66 and 83 years (Table 21.3) [37, 62, 66, 6984]. The incidence significantly rises with age to 190–312/million/year in individuals older than 80 years of age [26, 34, 37, 66]. With the changing age structure of the European population, even more people are expected to suffer from BP in the coming decades. In individuals younger than 50 years, BP rarely occurs (incidence of <0.5/million/year) [26, 34, 37, 85]. Only few cases of BP in children and adolescents have been reported. A study from Israel has indicated that infantile BP is not so rare with an estimated incidence rate of 2.36/100,000 persons per year [86].


Table 21.3
Mortality, risk factors, and associated diseases of bullous pemphigoid


























































































































Region and setting

Period

Mean (median) age

1-year mortality

Risk factors for death; associated diseases

USA [73] retrospective, monocenter

<1953a

66

24 %

n.d.

England [74] retrospective, monocenter

1975–1988

74

19 %

None identified

France [75] retrospective, 3 centers

1985–1992

79

41 %

Widespread disease, age >86 years, poor general condition, female sex

France [72] prospective, multicenter

1989–1992

79

n.d.

Aldosterone antagonists

Germany [76] prospective, multicenter

1987–1997

77

29 %

Age>80 years, prednisolone <37 mg/day, serum albumin <3.6 g/dl, ESR >30 mm/h

France prospective, multicenter all patients [77, 78] extensive disease only [79]

1996–1998

81

26 %

Age >83 years, Karnofsky score <40, dementia, Parkinsons disease, stroke

 Topical corticosteroids

81

24 %

n.d.

 Oral corticosteroids

81

41 %

n.d.

Scotland [66] retrospective, monocenter

1991–2001

79

25 %

n.d.

Switzerland [80] prospective, multicenter

2001–2002

76

21 %

Neurological diseases

USA [81] retrospective, 2 centers

1998–2003

75

23 %

Heart disease, diabetes, dementia, stroke

France [62] prospective, 3 centers

2000–2005

83

38 %

n.d.

Czechia [82] retrospective, 2 centers

1991–2006

(76)

n.d.

Neurological disease

UK [37, 70] general practice database

1996–2006

(80)

19 %

Stroke, dementia, Parkinson’s disease, epilepsy, multiple sclerosis

France [69] prospective, multicenter

2003–2007

82

n.d.

Bedridden condition, major cognitive impairment, Parkinson’s disease, uni- or bipolar disorders, spirono-lactone, phenothiazines

England [71] prospective, monocenter

2004–2008

82

n.d.

Stroke, dementia

Taiwan [83] National Health Insurance data

1997–2008

(74)

n.d.

Stroke, dementia, Parkinson’s disease, epilepsy, schizophrenia, psoriasis

Thailand [84] retrospective, monocenter

1991–2009

69
 
Diabetes mellitus, neurological diseases


aBefore corticosteroids became available; n.d., not determined


21.5.2 Mortality


The calculated mortality rates of BP significantly varied from one country to another and particularly between Europe and the USA. The first-year mortality rates ranged from 10.9 to 41 % which is about two- to sixfold higher compared to age- and sex-matched controls (Table 21.3) [37, 62, 80]. These differences are likely due to selection biases (inclusion of predominantly outpatients versus inpatients, patients in either bad or good general condition and/or with different access to medical care referral to tertiary centers). In fact, most of these previous studies were regional or hospital based. In one study, the standardized mortality ratio (SMR) ranged from 2 to 15 [80]. The increase risk of death was particularly high for people of less than 70 years. In this age group, the mortality can more easily be attributed to the BP, its treatments, and/or the comorbidities associated with this disease, since mortality from other causes does not probably dilute mortality from BP as it might be the case for the older age groups [37, 42].

In prospective studies, old age, low Karnofsky score, and presence of neurological disease were found to be negative predictors. In retrospective studies widespread disease and treatment modalities were shown to influence mortality (Table 21.3). Specifically, a higher mortality was observed in patients receiving initial prednisolone greater than 35 mg/day, while in patients with extensive disease, treatment with high-potency topical corticosteroids was associated with a lower 1-year mortality compared to oral corticosteroids at a dose of 1 mg/kg/day (24 % versus 41 %) [76, 79] (Table 21.3). Finally, a 1-year mortality rate as low as 8 % was observed when class IV corticosteroids in the initial phase, methylprednisolone 0.5 mg/kg/day, and dapsone were combined [87].


21.5.3 Associated Diseases


Neurological disorders have been identified to be highly associated with BP in the past years (Table 21.3). In fact, between a third and half of all BP patients suffer from neurological diseases (odds ratios 2.4–10.6.) [6971, 77, 80]. These findings are intriguing since both target antigens, BP180 and BP230 (BPAG1), are expressed in the central nervous system [88, 89], and mice with mutations in the dystonin gene encoding for various isoforms of BPAG1 including the epithelial isoform BP230 develop severe dystonia and sensory nerve degeneration [90]. Very recently, an association with psoriasis (odds ratio 2.0) was reported in Taiwanese patients [83]. In addition, case reports described the occurrence of BP with autoimmune disorders and cancer. However, a case-control study did not find any increased risk for autoimmune disorders [91], while in two case-control studies with more than 1,700 BP patients, a low association with gastric cancer was only observed in Japan [92, 93].


21.6 Mucous Membrane Pemphigoid


The incidence has been estimated between 0.9 and 1.3/million/a in Germany and France. In the early 1990s, 10 years later, the incidence appeared to have increased to 2.0/million/a [34, 61, 63]. The disease onset appeared to be earlier as in BP with a mean age of 60–65 years [9498]. Several investigators provided evidence indicating that about 30 % of patients with anti-laminin 332 (formerly known as laminin 5 and epiligrin) mucous membrane pemphigoid present with a solid cancer [99101]. No association with a malignancy was found in all mucous membrane pemphigoid irrespective of the target antigen as well as in patients with anti-α6β4 reactivity [102104]. Thus, the identification of the target antigen may be useful.


21.7 Pemphigoid Gestationis


The incidence of pemphigoid gestationis has been estimated in the range of 0.8 and 2.0/million/year in France, Germany, and Kuwait [12, 34, 61, 63]. A recent study in two English tertiary referral centers, however, found pemphigoid gestationis to arise in 4.2 % of pregnancies [105]. Previous data revealed frequencies of 1:60,000 (USA) [106], 1:50,000 (USA) [107], 1:44,000 (England) [108], 1:7,000 (Switzerland) [109], 1:3,000–4,000 (England) [110], and 1:3,000 (England, 1921–1955) pregnancies [111]. Individual cases have been described in association with hydatidiform moles and choriocarcinomas, without pregnancy [112].

Patients with pemphigoid gestationis show apparently an increased risk for other autoimmune disorders, such as Grave’s disease (in 10 %), hypothyroidism, alopecia areata, vitiligo, and autoimmune thrombocytopenia [112115].


21.8 Linear IgA Disease


An incidence of 0.25–1.0 patients with linear IgA disease/million/year was reported in Central Europe, Singapore, and Kuwait [12, 34, 63, 65]. Linear IgA disease is the most frequent pemphigoid disorder in children with two peaks of onset, below the age of 5 and after the age of 60 years [116]. The incidence appeared to be higher in developing countries such as Malaysia, India, Thailand, Tunisia, Mali, South Africa, and Uganda [7, 31, 117121]. This may be however related to the different age distribution of the population with up to half of the population being minors in developing countries. Since linear IgA disease sera, in addition to IgA, often also contain IgG antibodies to BP180, whereas most BP sera also have IgA anti-BP180 antibodies, these two diseases may represent different ends of the same spectrum [122]. In a study from Uganda, younger patients preferentially developed IgA anti-basal membrane zone autoantibodies, whereas the IgG isotype predominated in older patients [117]. A high frequency of lymphoproliferative disorders and ulcerative colitis compared to the general population has been found in linear IgA disease [123, 124].

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jun 3, 2017 | Posted by in Dermatology | Comments Off on Epidemiology of Autoimmune Bullous Diseases

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access