Topical Medications in Vitiligo


Drug

Mechanism of action

Level of evidence

Corticosteroids

Modulate the immune response by reducing the macrophages and T cells

Reduce autoantibodies

Inhibit complement-mediated melanocyte destruction

IA

Calcineurin inhibitors

Reduce the tissue counts of IFN-γ, IL-1, IL-2, IL-3, IL-4, IL-5, GM-CSF, TNF-α

Enhance melanocyte and melanoblast proliferation

IA (children)

IIA (adults)

Vitamin D3 analogs

Target the local immune response in vitiligo, by acting on specific T-cell activation

Inhibit the transition of T cells from early to late G1 phase

Inhibit the expression of TNF-α IFN-γ

Modulate melanocyte maturation and differentiation

Upregulates melanogenesis through pathways activated by vitamin D ligand receptors (endothelin receptor and c-kit) [2]

IIA (monotherapy), IB if combined with topical steroids

Photochemotherapy

Psoralens stimulate melanogenesis; photoconjugation of psoralens in melanocyte DNA leads to mitosis, replication and proliferation of melanocytes, increased number of melanosomes, and subsequent apocopation

PUVA stimulates the activity of cAMP; leads to increased synthesis of tyrosine, the precursor of melanin; induces a suppressor T-cell response which releases IL-10 suppressing the autoimmune stimulus responsible for the destruction of melanocytes

PUVA induces basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) and hepatocyte growth factor, leading to re-growth and migration of follicular melanocytes to stratum basale [35]

PUVA: IV

Khellin: III

L-Phenylalanine

Stimulates melanogenesis in vitiliginous patches

IIB

Monobenzyl ether of hydroquinone (MBEH)

Reacts with tyrosinase to form a reactive quinone product that binds to cysteine residues in tyrosinase proteins to form hapten-carrier complexes causing destruction of melanocytes

Induces lysosomal degradation of melanosomes by autophagy

A contact sensitizer inducing a delayed-type hypersensitivity response [6]

IV

Antioxidants

Increase catalase activity leading to a decrease in reactive oxygen species

Inhibit ROS-mediated destruction of melanocytes

IB

5-Fluorouracil

Direct stimulation of melanocyte proliferation

Inhibits agents or cytotoxic cells which destroy melanocytes

Immunomodulator stabilizing the vitiligo disease [7]

IV

Piperine

Stimulates the proliferation of melanocytes [8]

IV

Prostaglandin E2

Increases melanocyte proliferation and density

IB

Capsaicin and curcumin

Inhibit apoptosis of melanocytes

Reduce the generation of ROS and lipid peroxidation

Improve mitochondrial activity

Enhance survival of melanocytes

IB





26.2 Topical Corticosteroids (TCS)


Topical steroids are the first-line drugs for the management of vitiligo. They are responsible for reduction of macrophages and T lymphocytes in vitiliginous patches [9], they likewise reduce the complement-mediated destruction of melanocytes [10]. In children and adults with limited, extrafacial involvement, once-daily application of potent steroids is advisable for not more than 3 months [11]. The response to this therapy is better in children as compared to adults. Moreover, lesions over the head and neck region respond well [12].

There are multiple studies supporting the efficacy of topical corticosteroids. Kwinter et al. reported response rates of 64 % in a study conducted on children who were treated with TCS alone [13]. Complete repigmentation rates are approximately 49.3 % [14].

The efficacy has been compared with other agents. When compared with topical calcineurin inhibitors, the response is equivocal to high [14, 15]. Repigmentation rates are however the same when compared with ultraviolet A (UVA) light phototherapy [16].

Even though TCS are very effective in the treatment of vitiligo, local side effects and topical steroid abuse limit the ultimate use of these agents. Skin atrophy, telangiectasia, hypertrichosis, acneiform eruptions, and striae caused by potent or very potent TCS are well known. Moreover, systemic absorption should be kept in mind while treating large areas of skin, thin skin and children with potent steroids. Lower potency TCS and newer class III TCS, like mometasone furoate and methylprednisolone aceponate, are devoid of these untoward side effects [11].


26.3 Topical Calcineurin Inhibitors (TCI)


Calcineurin, when activated, leads to transcription of IL-2 and TNF-α. Vitiliginous patches were found to have elevated levels of these cytokines. Inhibitors of calcineurin, like tacrolimus and pimecrolimus, are extremely effective in treating vitiligo, by increasing the proliferation of both melanoblasts and melanocytes [17]. This is particularly useful for new and actively spreading lesions on thin skin, as an alternative to TCS. Initially, twice-daily applications are recommended. If effective, the duration of use may be extended to 12 months [11]. The onset of action is earlier in comparison to TCS but the repigmentation is inferior. Occlusion may help in cases of recalcitrant lesions on the extremities [18]. Lesions on the head and neck are the most responsive, with the rates ranging from 63 to 89 % [1921].

When combined with other agents, the response is even better. Topical tacrolimus combined with NB-UVB was reported to have repigmentation rates of greater than 50 % in 42 % of lesions in patients with chronic stable refractory vitiligo [22]. Similar results were also reported by Nordal et al. [23]. Also, combination with 308 nm excimer laser was reported to have a very high response rate of 100 % [24].

In controlled trials among the pediatric age group, efficiency of tacrolimus was compared with that of fluticasone, mometasone, and clobetasol, with a conclusion of similar efficiency of steroids and tacrolimus [2528]. Moreover, tacrolimus in combination with oral prednisolone was effective in recent-onset vitiligo [29].

TCIs are safe for short-term or intermittent long-term use, side effects being erythema, pruritus, burning, irritation, and rarely hyperpigmentation and acne [3033]. According to the FDA, topical tacrolimus should not be used in patients less than 2 years of age, and only 0.03 % tacrolimus is approved for patients aged 2–15 years [34]. Tacrolimus 0.1 % ointment with excimer laser is superior to placebo for UV-resistant areas. When used alone, the efficacy of tacrolimus 0.1 % ointment is similar to clobetasol propionate 0.05 % ointment. Pimecrolimus 1 % cream combined with narrow-band UVB is superior to placebo, especially for facial lesions [35].


26.4 Topical Vitamin D3 Analogs


Calcipotriene is an effective adjunct to topical corticosteroids in the treatment of vitiligo, on account of its immunomodulatory and proliferative effects on melanocytes. Even though advocated as a good add-on therapy, there are reports of repigmentation in children when used as a monotherapy [36, 37]. Combination with TCS provided the maximum benefit and was shown to be safe for both children and adults [1]. Moreover, there was increase in repigmentation rates, earlier-onset of repigmentation, and, most importantly, greater stability of repigmentation [38, 39].

Newman and Silverberg found that topical calcipotriene and betamethasone dipropionate is a promising combination to treat facial vitiligo [40]. Calcipotriene, however, is not effective when combined with NB-UVB [25, 4143].


26.5 Photochemotherapy (Psoralens, Khellin, and L-Phenylalanine)



26.5.1 Psoralens


Photochemotherapy with topical 8-methoxypsoralen (8-MOP) can be used in patients with lesions covering less than 5 % body surface area and also in children less than 12 years of age (systemic PUVA is contraindicated). However, topical psoralens may lead to significant pruritus, erythema, edema, blisters, and skin necrosis even with minimum dosage. Thus, therapy with these agents mandates strict monitoring [1]. Application of 0.001 % 8-MOP or less, one to three times per week for 20–30 min, is recommended. The skin is then exposed to UVA radiation at 0.25–0.5 J/cm2. The exposure time is increased by 15–30 s in subsequent sessions (maximum 10 min). This procedure has to be repeated until a dosage and exposure time are attained which produces erythema but not burning. Post-procedural advice is crucial to avoid untoward adverse effects. The patients should wash away the excess 8-MOP with soap and water immediately after the irradiation and apply UVA sunscreen to avoid additional environmental UVA exposure [44]. The advantage of topical PUVA is the need for fewer treatments and considerably smaller cumulative UVA doses, lower plasma levels, and reduced systemic and ocular phototoxicity [11].


26.5.2 Khellin


Khellin is a furanochrome extract of the plant Ammi visnaga (5,8-dimethoxy-2 methyl-4,5-furo-6,7 chromone). KUVA refers to khellin followed by UVA. It has a stimulatory effect on melanogenesis and melanocyte proliferation when combined with UVA light. Khellin can be topically applied in a moisturizing cream or Carbopol gel (3–5 %). Topical “KUVA-sun” is still used in sunny countries. It has been studied and found that topical khellin followed by UVA (KUVA) does not provide any significant benefit in patients with vitiligo [45, 46]. It is rather effective when given orally, but it has been abandoned.


26.5.3 Phenylalanine


Since phenylalanine is an essential amino acid responsible for initiation of melanogenesis, it is used as a photosensitizer for topical and/or oral supplementation of natural or artificial UVA light phototherapy in the management of vitiligo. The best responders are patients with less than 25 % body surface area involvement, with onset of disease before 21 years of age, and those having generalized and symmetrical lesions [47]. Lotti et al. reported a significant repigmentation in 29.3 % of patients applying topical L-phenylalanine as monotherapy [48]. The addition of topical L-phenylalanine to oral L-phenylalanine and light therapy makes it even more effective [49, 50].


26.6 Topical Depigmenting Agents


Topical agents like hydroquinone (HQ) and monobenzone induce melanocyte death, and these have been approved by the FDA for vitiligo [51]. It should be noted that depigmenting agents should be used in patients with extensive disfiguring vitiligo, and definitely when trial of conventional therapies have failed [11]. Unlike HQ, monobenzyl ether of hydroquinone (MBEH) always causes irreversible depigmentation [52]. A thin layer of MBEH 20 % cream is applied two to three times daily in a uniform manner and rubbed into the pigmented area. Since the depigmenting effect is significantly reduced on exposure to sunlight, prolonged exposure to sunlight is not permissible during treatment, or a sunscreen should be used. Depigmentation is achieved after 1–4 months. The drug should be withdrawn if there is no response after 4 months of treatment. However, if the desired degree of depigmentation is obtained, the drug should be continued in a maintenance dosage (twice weekly) [11].

The response rates range from 40 to 80 % [52]. Side effects include burning, itching, contact dermatitis, conjunctival melanosis, pingueculae, and corneal pigment deposition [1]. There are reports of development of resistance to treatment. To overcome this, prescribing MBEH with retinoic acid has been proposed [53].


26.7 Comparison of Various Topical Therapies


Clobetasol was shown to be superior in efficacy compared to pimecrolimus [54], but considering the adverse-effect profile of TCS, tacrolimus can be a better option [14]. Besides, the results with pimecrolimus is variable [55], thus re-establishing tacrolimus as a better option [21, 56]. However, pimecrolimus in combination with phototherapy is definitely a good option [57]. But, the combination of calcipotriol with TCS is the most favorable therapeutic modality with respect to the efficacy and safety profile, especially when applied on Indian skin [38].


26.8 Newer Drugs



26.8.1 Antioxidants


Recent advances in the etiopathogenesis of vitiligo suggest the role of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in the inhibition of melanogenesis. Therapy with antioxidants (topical and oral) leads to increased catalase activity and a decrease in ROS [58]. Combining oral and topical phenylalanine gives good results [59]. Moreover, Schallreuter et al. reported remarkable repigmentation on the face and hands of patients who were put on topical pseudocatalase with short-term UVB [60]. Sanclemente et al. concluded that topical catalase is as effective as 0.05 % betamethasone in vitiligo [61]. Side effects associated with the use of topical catalase/superoxide dismutase include transient erythema, pruritus, and peeling [61, 62].


26.8.2 Topical 5-Fluorouracil (5-FU)


Topical 5-FU has been studied for the treatment of vitiligo. It is hypothesized that direct overstimulation of melanocyte proliferation, inhibition of agents able to destroy melanocytes, and immunomodulation stabilizing the vitiligo disease could be responsible for the efficacy of 5-FU in vitiligo. However, topical application of 5-FU alone cannot induce any pigment spread in vitiligo patients; application on a dermabraded or ablated epidermis could cause a long-lasting and favorable pigment spread [7, 25, 63].


26.8.3 Piperine


Piperine and its analogs, PIP [5-(3,4-methylenedioxyphenyl)-2,4-pentadienoylpiperidine], tetrahydropiperine [THP, 5-(3,4-methylenedioxyphenyl)-pentanoylpiperidine], a cyclohexyl analog of piperine [CHP, 5-(3,4-methylenedioxyphenyl)-2,4-pentadienoylcyclohexylamine], and reduced CHP [rCHP, 5-(3,4-methylenedioxyphenyl)-2,4-pentanoylcyclohexylamine], have been reported to stimulate melanocyte replication in vitro and may be useful in treating vitiligo [8]. Treatments with these compounds and concomitant cutaneous exposure to ultraviolet (UV) radiation are better in efficacy than UV radiation alone [64].


26.8.4 Prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) Analogs


PGE2, by virtue of its growth-stimulatory effects, is capable of regulating the proliferation and maturation of melanocytes [65]. Kapoor et al. studied the efficacy and safety of topical PGE2 in the treatment of stable vitiligo (<5 % body surface area). Excellent response was seen in 55 % of patients. Side effects in the form of a transient burning sensation especially on the lips were reported in a few patients [66, 67].


26.8.5 Capsaicin and Curcumin


Treatment with these antioxidants inhibits caspase-induced apoptosis, increases the total antioxidant capacity of the body, decreases the generation of ROS and lipid peroxidation, and improves mitochondrial activity. Moreover, C. melo extracts have shown superoxide dismutase and catalase-like activities [68]. Thus, topical capsaicin and extracts of C. melo might protect against vitiligo progression [69]. However, well-designed randomized clinical trials are needed to support the use of these extracts for vitiligo because of conflicting reports regarding its effectiveness and efficacy [67, 70].


26.8.6 Camouflage


Keeping in mind the significant psychosocial trauma associated with vitiligo, camouflage has a considerable role in the management [71]. There is a wide choice of self-tanning agents; stains; dyes; whitening lotions; tinted cover creams; compact, liquid, and stick foundations; fixing powders; fixing sprays; cleansers; semipermanent and permanent tattoos; and dyes for pigmenting facial and scalp white hairs [11]. The results are even more gratifying in cases of vitiligo in children [72]. Dihydroxyacetone (DHA), one of the most effective camouflage agents, is an active ingredient of sunless tanners. DHA is an easy and convenient option for patients who want to camouflage their vitiligo, because the stain lasts up to 10 days. It reacts with proteins of the stratum corneum and forms brown chromophores called melanoidins, which temporarily impart a golden brown color to the skin [73]. The amount of tanning is proportional to the concentration of DHA used [74]. Thus, it becomes easy for the patient to choose the concentration of DHA that most closely matches their skin color [75, 76].

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Aug 20, 2017 | Posted by in Dermatology | Comments Off on Topical Medications in Vitiligo

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access