The Role of Alternative Medicine in Rhinology




Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) includes treatments from traditional Chinese medicine, homeopathy, naturopathy, herbal medicine, Ayurvedic medicine, mind-body medicine, chiropractic or osteopathic manipulations, and massage. More than 40% of patients in the United States use CAM, with 17% of CAM use related to otolaryngology diagnoses, but nearly half of CAM users do not communicate their use of these medications to their physicians. Perioperative risk of bleeding is a particular concern in surgical specialties, and knowledge of these therapies and their potential adverse effects is critical.








  • Approximately 40% of people in the United States used complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) therapies in the past year.



  • 17% of CAM therapies target otolaryngologic and rhinologic diagnoses, primarily allergic rhinitis, infectious rhinitis, and sinusitis.



  • Nearly half of all CAM users do not communicate their use of these medications to their physicians.



  • Perioperative risk of bleeding, anesthetic interactions, and other complications are possible with certain CAM medications.



  • Preoperative evaluations must include a thorough history of any CAM use, and appropriate timing of discontinuation of these medications.



Summary/Key Points


Complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) describes a broad category of practices and treatments for the prevention or treatment of disease outside of the realm of conventional medicine. CAM includes many types of interventions, from medications and supplements to physical therapies and procedures, and encompasses traditional Chinese medicine (herbal treatments and acupuncture therapy), homeopathy, naturopathy, herbal medicine, Ayurvedic medicine, mind-body medicine, chiropractic or osteopathic manipulations, and massage.


There is growing interest in and use of CAM, with CAM therapies for atopic conditions second only to treatments for back pain, creating significant overlap of CAM with otolaryngology and rhinology. In 2007, 40% of adults in the United States had used at least 1 type of CAM in the previous year, nearly doubling in the past 20 years, with current reports of 15% in Canada, 25% in the United Kingdom, and 50% use in Australia. Fluctuation in the use of CAM over time seems to be influenced by cost, accessibility, failure of conventional medical therapies, cultural influences, and portrayal of CAM in the media.


Popular conceptions of CAM as natural or harmless may also contribute to underreporting of CAM use, with patients often perceiving CAM or herbal medications to be a separate entity from traditional medications. Between 40% and 70% of patients do not discuss their herbal medications, supplements, or other CAM therapeutics with their physicians, and may not realize that a specific therapy is categorized as CAM. Conflicting pharmacodynamics, direct effects, and side effects of these undisclosed medications may lead to herb-drug interactions and adverse effects. Direct questioning from physicians is the strongest factor correlated with improved disclosure of CAM therapies, but many physicians are unaware of the prevalence of CAM or its potential uses and risks. Evidence-based data on CAM therapies are often limited in depth or quality, or simply difficult to find in readily available publications. The rapid increase of CAM-related publications in otolaryngology in the past decade highlights a growing awareness of CAM in the specialty, as well as the continuing need for data evaluating of the efficacy and safety of these therapies.


Rhinology and complementary medicine


CAM is used for otolaryngology-specific ailments including allergic rhinitis, sinusitis, facial headache, tinnitus, and vertigo, with 17% of CAM use related to otolaryngologic diagnoses. Sinusitis (chronic, acute, and allergic) and rhinitis (allergic, vasomotor, and infectious) are common targets of CAM in rhinology, with up to 30% of patients with chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) using alternative herbal therapy before seeking conventional medical intervention. Although conventional treatments for rhinitis or sinusitis typically include decongestants, antihistamines, steroids, antibiotics, and surgery, described CAM treatment options for rhinologic disease vary widely. Common types of CAM rhinologic treatments include nutritional supplements, herbal medications, homeopathy (use of diluted extracts), acupuncture (use of needles to affect physiologic function), aromatherapy, chiropractic (treatment by spinal manipulation), osteopathy (treatment of underlying mechanical disorders), and phototherapy (treatment with light). Details of many available CAM treatments are described in Table 1 , including their active compounds, possible indications, and methods of use, as well as significant drug interactions and adverse effects.



Table 1

Herbs in treatment of nasal conditions







































































































Medication Use Mechanism Adverse Effects
Supplements
Ascorbic acid Acute infectious rhinitis Inhibition of histamine release Kidney stones, diarrhea, delayed healing, increased iron absorption in blood-iron disorders, worsening sickle cell disease
Capsaicin Allergic rhinitis Inhibition of substance P, IL-6 production Localized irritation
Fish oil Allergic rhinitis, antiinflammatory Reduced production and effectiveness of prostaglandins Dose-related increase on bleeding time, hypotension
Spirulina Allergic rhinitis, antiinflammatory Inhibition of histamine release, reduced IL-4, increased IgA production Hepatotoxicity, heavy-metal contamination
Herbal medications
Bromelain Sinusitis, allergic rhinitis, mucolytic, antiinflammatory Proteolysis, inhibition of prostaglandins GI upset, rare allergic reaction
Garlic Acute infectious rhinitis, cough, URI Inhibition of prostaglandins, thromboxanes Inhibition of cytochrome P450 metabolism, decreased platelet aggregation, potentiation of warfarin effect
Quercetin Antiinflammatory, antihistamine Antioxidant, inhibition of cyclooxygenase to reduce leukotrienes, prostaglandins; mast cell stabilizer None reported
Butterbur Allergic rhinitis Inhibition of leukotriene and histamine synthesis, mast cell stabilizer Raw butterbur extract alkaloids are hepatotoxic, carcinogenic; rare GI upset
Sinupret Allergic rhinosinusitis Mucolytic, antiviral, antiinflammatory Kidney stones, allergic reactions, GI upset, numbness, dermatitis
Echinacea Acute infectious rhinitis Activation of T, B lymphocytes GI upset, headache, muscular ache, dizziness; hepatotoxicity with prolonged use
Esberitox Acute sinusitis Immune stimulation Rash, itching, facial swelling, vertigo, hypotension
Cineole Acute rhinosinusitis Antiinflammatory, increased ciliary movement Reflux, headache, nausea
Angelica URI, allergic rhinitis, cough, expectorant Inhibition of prostaglandin E2 Photosensitivity
Ephedra Nasal congestion Increased activity of noradrenaline on adrenergic receptors Tachycardia, palpitations, hallucinations, hypertension, paranoia
Licorice root Allergic rhinitis Antiinflammatory, inhibition of 11-β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase, complement pathway Hypokalemia, muscle ache, numbness, pseudoaldosteronism
N -Acetylcysteine Sinusitis, mucolytic Cleavage of disulfide bonds in mucoprotein Rare GI upset
Shi-bi-lin Allergic rhinitis, sneezing, nasal itching Inhibition of IL-4 and TNF-α None reported
Xiao-qing-long-tang Infectious rhinitis, allergic rhinitis Inhibition of histamine signaling, IL-4 and IL-5 None reported

Abbreviations: Ig, immunoglobulin; IL, interleukin; GI, gastrointestinal; TNF, tumor necrosis factor; URI, upper respiratory infection.


Nutritional Supplements


Ascorbic acid, or vitamin C, is used to treat infectious rhinitis (common cold) with 1 to 3 g by mouth daily, and allergic rhinitis as an intranasal topical medication. It seems to inhibit histamine secretion by lymphocytes, showing an inverse correlation of plasma ascorbic acid levels with histamine levels. Although ascorbic acid does not prevent acute viral rhinitis from the common cold, it may shorten the disease course by 1 to 1.5 days. Comparisons of intranasal ascorbic acid with placebo in allergic rhinitis have shown decreased nasal secretions, congestion, and edema in subjects treated with ascorbic acid solution. Potential severe side effects include kidney stones, severe diarrhea, delayed healing, increased iron absorption in blood-iron disorders (thalassemia, hemochromatosis), and worsening of sickle cell disease. Drug interactions include decreased effectiveness of HIV/AIDS medications amprenavir (Agenerase), nelfinavir (Viracept), ritonavir (Norvir), and saquinavir (Fortovase, Invirase). Large amounts of ascorbic acid may decrease the effectiveness of warfarin (Coumadin), requiring dose alterations, and can delay the metabolism of aspirin, potentiating its effects.


Capsaicin (8-methyl- n -vanillyl-6-nonenamide) is the natural product of chili peppers that produces their burning heat. It is assumed to block neuropeptides like substance P, affecting pain transmission. Substance P is also released from nasal mucosal cells, interacting with nasal innervation and increasing interleukin (IL)-6 production, potentially at greater levels in allergic rhinitis. Capsaicin is used in topical applications for pain relief from muscular soreness and peripheral neuropathy, but investigations of capsaicin for treatment of allergic rhinitis to dust mites did not find any therapeutic effect. No drug interactions are known, and systemic side effects are rare, but localized irritation can occur at the application site.


Fish oil contains eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic (DHA) acids, ω-3 fatty acids known to have antiinflammatory properties benefiting chronic inflammatory conditions. Similarly, cod liver oil, produced from the livers of cod, halibut, and other white fish, contains long-chain fatty acids as well as vitamin D, and shares the antiinflammatory properties of fish oil. Reduced intake of fish oil fatty acids may be associated with an increase in allergic rhinitis prevalence. Limited benefit has been shown in other allergic diagnoses like asthma and atopic dermatitis. However, information on the effects of fish oil on allergic rhinitis is minimal or conflicting between studies, with one double-blinded, placebo-controlled study resulting in no significant differences, whereas cross-sectional studies may show reduced prevalence of allergic rhinitis with increased intake of fish oil. The ω-3 fatty acids exert a dose-related increase on bleeding time, and should be used with caution in patients with bleeding disorders, on blood-thinning medications, or before elective surgery. Fish oil can decrease blood pressure and increase the effect of hypertensive medications, leading to hypotension.


Spirulina is dried filamentous cyanobacteria from blue-green algae Arthospira platensis and is high in protein, vitamin B12 and provitamin A (β-carotenes), and minerals like iron. It is known to have antiinflammatory effects through inhibition of histamine release from mast cells, and high doses of spirulina significantly reduce IL-4 in the immunoglobulin (Ig)-E–mediated allergy pathway, and enhance IgA production. One randomized-control trial confirmed the decrease in IL-4 and improvement in nasal symptom scores in patients with allergic rhinitis after 6 months of spirulina dosing. Hepatotoxicity and reactions from heavy-metal contamination have been reported but no drug interactions are known.


Herbal Medications


Bromelain is a stem and fruit extract from pineapple ( Ananas comosus ) containing a proteolytic enzyme complex that has been used as a mucolytic and antiinflammatory. Use of bromelain has been shown to thin nasal mucus secretions, and is an effective mucolytic for the respiratory tract. Proteolysis at sites of inflammation also seems to inhibit the production proinflammatory prostaglandins like prostaglandin E1. A recent study from 2005 found statistically faster symptomatic recovery from sinusitis with bromelain compared with placebo. Possible side effects are gastrointestinal upset and rare allergic reactions, with possible overlap with allergies to pineapple, wheat, celery, papain, carrot, fennel, cypress pollen, or grass pollen. Oral dosing of bromelain is typically 500 to 1000 mg/d or up to 2000 mg.


Garlic ( Allium sativum ) is often used for treatment of cough, viral upper respiratory infections, and rhinitis by oral dosing or direct nasal topical application. Potential adverse effects include rare allergic reactions, hypoglycemia, and prolonged bleeding time. Garlic also influences the cytochrome P450 system, potentiating the anticoagulant effect of warfarin. Alterations of pharmacokinetics may also interfere with paracetamol and chlorpropamide, resulting in hypoglycemia, or ampicillin with increased minimal inhibitory concentration reported. Garlic is associated with decreased platelet aggregation within 5 days of oral dosing in a dose-dependent manner, with the possible mechanism being from inhibition of epinephrine-induced platelet aggregation. Irreversible platelet effects from ajolene, another active compound in garlic, can increase the effects of other platelet inhibitors. Discontinuing garlic intake 1 week before elective surgery is suggested. Although few published reports of bleeding complications have been connected to garlic, there are definitive reports of increased international normalized ratios (INRs) and prothrombin times with coinciding garlic and coumadin dosing.


Quercetin (3,3′,4′,5-7-pentahydroxyflavone) is a plant-derived flavonoid found in fruits, vegetables, leaves, and grains and exhibits in vitro antiinflammatory activity from antioxidant properties and inhibition of inflammatory enzymes (cyclooxygenase and lipooxygenase, regulators of leukotrienes and prostaglandins). In addition,, quercetin is able to stabilize mast cells to inhibit the release of histamine, even after IgE activation, and provides a clinical function similar to cromolyn sodium, although no definitive evidence of effect has been shown in clinical trials. Oral dosing with 400 to 500 mg 3 times daily is common. No side effects have been reported, but quercetin may lessen the effects of quinolone antibiotics, and these should not be taken simultaneously.


Butterbur ( Petsites hybridus ) is an extract from the leaves and roots of the butterbur shrub, and contains the active ingredient sesquiterpenes (petasins) that may inhibit leukotriene, mast cell degranulation, and histamine synthesis. Butterbur has been shown to significantly reduce the symptoms of allergic rhinitis in randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled studies, and is similar in efficacy to cetirizine and fexofenadine, although other studies showed minimal effect. Critical to the safety profile of butterbur is the processing of raw butterbur extract to remove pyrrolizidine alkaloids that are hepatotoxic and carcinogenic. Petasin is a processed butterbur extract with the alkaloids removed, and is approved for allergic rhinitis treatment in Switzerland. Adverse effects include only rare gastrointestinal complaints, although the mechanism of action and long-term effects are poorly understood.


Sinupret is a herbal preparation used widely in Europe, including extracts of elder flowers ( Sambucus nigra ), cowslip flowers ( Primula veris ), common sorrel ( Rumex acetosa ), European vervain ( Verbena officinalis ), and gentain ( Gentaina lutea ) root. Of 4 larger studies, 3 showed positive efficacy with antiviral, antiinflammatory, and mucus-thinning properties. Reported adverse events included kidney stones, allergic reactions, gastrointestinal symptoms, numbness, and mild dermatitis. Sinupret interacts with therapeutic monoclonal antibodies (eg, adalimumab [Humira], bevacizumab [Avastin], infliximab [Remicade], and omalizumab [Xolair]), hypertensive medications, and immunosuppressants (tacrolimus, methotrexate, corticosteroids, mycophenolate, etanercept, and cyclosporine), and is not recommended in patients with hypertension, immunosuppression, or a history of kidney stones.


Echinacea ( Echinacea purpurea leaf and Echinacea pallida contain active components) is a herb shown to activate T and B lymphocytes in vitro, leading to a potential application for viral rhinitis symptoms, and although several meta-analyses found positive effects, some studies have shown no effect. As is true with many herbal medications, commercially available formulations of echinacea also vary widely in amount and type of active compounds, further complicating effective studies. Gastrointestinal upset, tongue numbness, headache, muscular aches, and dizziness can occur, and echinacea has been associated with hepatotoxicity after prolonged use beyond 8 weeks. Echinacea can delay the metabolism of caffeine, causing tachycardia and nervousness, and it increases the activity of the immune system, which could directly counteract any immune-suppressive medications.


Esberitox contains 3 herbs ( Thuja occidentalis , Echinacea angustifolia , and Baptisia tinctoria ) and acts as an immune stimulant. Studies comparing Esberitox with placebo and other CAM and traditional therapies showed good effect as an adjunct to doxycycline for treatment of acute sinusitis, with significant effect compared with placebo. No drug interactions are known, but uncommon side effects like rashes, itching, facial swelling, vertigo, and hypotension have been described.


Stinging nettle ( Urtica doica ) is used for the treatment of allergic rhinitis, but double-blind randomized studies have shown no, or only subjective, benefit.


Myrtol is a herbal extract with components from Pinus spp (pine), Citrus aurantifolia (lime), and Eucalyptus globulus . Some effect compared with placebo has been shown, with symptom reduction similar to other herbal therapies but insufficient data to show significance. Possible adverse effects included gastrointestinal disturbance, facial swelling and allergic reactions, and taste disturbances.


Cineole (eucalyptol or 1,8-cineole) is an active molecule extracted from eucalyptus oil for use in medications, with possible antiinflammatory benefits, as well as effect on ciliary movement with increased beat frequency. It has been shown to augment the effectiveness of nasal decongestants for the treatment of acute rhinosinusitis compared with placebo, particularly when dosed early in the course of an infection. Mild side effects such as reflux, headache, and nausea have been reported from Cineole, but possible serious side effects from pure eucalyptus oil are well known. Undiluted eucalyptus oil is potentially very toxic, through both oral and topical dosing, and 3.5 mL of undiluted oil can be fatal. Signs of eucalyptus poisoning are dizziness, weakness, mydriasis, shortness of breath, and abdominal pain or burning.


Angelica ( Angelica archangelica ) or danngui is commonly used for upper respiratory illnesses, allergies, and coughs as an expectorant. Some inhibitory effect on prostaglandin E2 is seen, as well as inhibition of the cytochrome P450 pathway, although the mechanism of action is not known. Side effects like photosensitivity may occur.


Ephedra ( Ephedra sinica ) or ma huang contains high levels of ephedrine, and is often used for asthma, bronchitis, and nasal congestion, and as a weight loss aid and stimulant. The action of ephedrine can also lead to many serious side effects like tachycardia, palpitations, hallucinations, hypertension, paranoia, and potentially death, leading to a ban of ephedra in the United States. There are multiple interactions with drugs like glycosides and halothane causing arrhythmias and potentiation of monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs).


Licorice root ( Glycyrrhiza glabra ) is used in the treatment of allergic rhinitis, conjunctivitis, and bronchitis as an antiinflammatory, and antiviral activity has been noted on in vitro studies. Licorice is known to inhibit 11-β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase and the classic complement pathway, and side effects can include hypokalemia, muscle pain, extremity numbness, and pseudoaldosteronism, which leads to hypertension, headaches, and cardiac events. Risk for adverse events is higher with large doses, but can occur at low doses as well. Licorice also interferes with angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE)–inhibitors, diuretics, corticosteroids, insulin and other diabetic drugs, MAOIs, oral contraceptives, and digoxin, where licorice can dangerously increase the toxicity of digoxin.


N -acetylcysteine (NAC) is used in the treatment of sinusitis primarily for its mucolytic properties, achieved through cleavage of disulfide bonds in mucoproteins by its sulfhydryl group resulting in less-viscous mucus. No serious side effects are known, but occasional gastrointestinal disturbances can occur. Adult dose is 600 to 1500 mg a day split into 8-hourly doses.


Ayurvedic Medicine


Ayurvedic medicine (from the Sanskrit ayur meaning life, and veda meaning science) is a traditional medical ideology originating in India with the goal of balancing the body, mind, and spirit through herbal medications, massage, and specific diets. More than 600 multiherb formulas and 250 single-herb medications are included in the Ayurvedic repertoire, including Aller-7 and Tinofend, which have been described for use in allergic rhinitis.


Aller-7 is a formulation of herbal extracts including quercetin, stinging nettles, methylsulfonylmethane, turmeric, feverfew, ginger, and vitamin C. It has shown some improvement in allergic rhinitis symptoms by possibly reducing inflammation.


Tinofend is a herbal tablet of Tinospora cordifolia that has shown efficacy compared with placebo; however, no studies have comprehensive data supporting the use of Aller-7 or Tinofend for allergic rhinitis.


Chinese traditional medicine


Shi-bi-lin is a Chinese herbal medication used for sneezing and nasal itching associated with allergic rhinitis, and is thought to act by inhibiting release of IL-4 and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)–α. Animal trials have shown efficacy and decreased eosinophil infiltration. Human safety trials are in progress, with similar improvement in symptoms to placebo, but a prolonged effect.


Xiao-qing-long-tang (Sho-seiryu-to in Japanese, or TJ-19) consists of extracts from 8 herbs, including ephedra. It is used for infectious rhinitis, asthma, and allergic rhinitis, and shows inhibition of histamine signaling and IL-4 and IL-5 expression in rat models.


Acupuncture is commonly used for CRS in Chinese traditional medicine, and 5% of adults in the United States have tried acupuncture for CRS. These techniques are thought to reduce inflammation and lead to desensitization to underlying allergy. One study evaluating efficacy of acupuncture showed a nonsignificant improvement in CRS symptoms over several weeks of acupuncture therapy compared with conventional treatment.


Other therapies


Homeopathy involves treatment with stimulating active agents dosed at ultradiluted amounts based on an individual’s symptomatic response. Studies of homeopathic treatments vary in evidence-based reports of benefit, and occasionally have been shown to worsen symptoms.


Phototherapy uses topical illumination with specific wavelengths of light to prompt an immunosuppressive response. This technique reduces antigen presentation by dendritic cells and inhibits proinflammatory factors, decreasing nasal symptom scores and levels of IL-5 and eosinophils.


Nasosympatico treatment stimulates and medicates the nasal mucosa directly by applying essential oils directly to the sinus ostia on soft cotton swabs.


Nasal saline irrigation provides benefits of mechanical clearing of mucus, thinner mucus, and improved mucociliary clearance at minimal cost or risk to the patient. Isotonic and hypertonic saline nasal rinses have been shown to significantly improve the symptoms of rhinosinusitis. Isotonic saline rinses significantly increased mucociliary clearance time in acute rhinosinusitis; however, hypertonic saline rinses improved clearance time only in patients with chronic sinusitis.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Feb 8, 2017 | Posted by in General Surgery | Comments Off on The Role of Alternative Medicine in Rhinology

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access