Chapter 7 Acne is either non-inflammatory or inflammatory. Classic comedones (the plugs in the pores) show no significant inflammation during their early development whether these are open comedones (blackheads) or closed comedones (whiteheads). There is no inflammation until the immune systems recognize a problem. From that instant until all is returned to normal, acne is inflammatory, even though the inflammation may be so subtle as to be invisible. The body has two separate and very different types of immunity, one that is present at the time of birth (innate or inborn immunity) and a second system that adapts to new threats and acquires new responses as a result (adaptive or acquired immunity). This chapter examines the innate and adaptive immune responses and their effects on the acnes. The innate immune system is the “first responder.” It developed during our evolutionary process when our primordial ancestors’ bodies needed to learn to neutralize or get rid of anything that penetrated their “skin” very quickly, or else they would die. The innate immune system developed over millions of years and it can respond to all sorts of different foreign materials and threats, from jellyfish to splinters and from ingrown hairs to viruses. This is the defensive system we are all born with. That means it can get to work immediately. This detection and reaction system works fast because there are millions of “sentry posts” just under the skin. They are continuously alert for any strange “foreign” material and can respond instantly, releasing a cascade of chemical messengers that either provide instant response or call for additional help. The sentries that are the backbone of the innate immune system are the toll-like receptors, or TLRs. Each type of TLR (and there are 13 in humans) has evolved to respond to defined stimuli. Some are quite specific and respond to only one stimulus. Others respond to more than one stimulus, and sometimes two or more TLRs will respond to the same stimulus. The combinations are complex and beyond the discussion here, but there are some general rules to illustrate the point. Bacterial lipoproteins (what bacterial cell walls are made of) are recognized by TLR1 and TLR2. Yeast wall materials (like Malassezia) trigger TLR2 and TLR6, but those two are also turned on by bacterial lipoproteins (Propionibacterium acnes again). Some viral material turns on TLR4; other viral material does the same for TLR7, TLR8, and TLR9; but TLR9 also triggers a reaction to bacterial material as well [1]. Experimental work in acne has specifically confirmed that both TLR2 and TLR4 are activated by P. acnes, while TLR2 responds to Malassezia [2]. Once the TLR “receptor” sees a threat it recognizes, it pushes the panic button and a vast number of events take place. In general, two types of messengers are produced, cytokines (the cell movers) and chemokines (the chemical movers). The cytokines send a message to cells, like the white blood cells called polys (polymorphonuclear leukocytes, or PMNLs), to come to help get rid of the invader. There is a crossover here with the adaptive immune system (see Section 7.2) because some of the cytokines will call for help from lymphocytes and others involve even more complex combinations of cells. The chemokines cause a vast array of chemical responses, from something as simple as releasing histamine to the complex chemical cascade that causes clotting. As a well-coordinated system, evolved over millions of years, the innate immune system does its best to identify, isolate, neutralize, and eliminate the foreign material. If the body needs more weapons than are available to the innate system alone, it has the capacity to call for further help: the body has evolved the additional ability to adapt itself to any new threat, threats for which the innate system has not evolved an instant response. This second level of defense is the adaptive immune response. The second kind of immunity is called adaptive because it needs to learn to adapt. Acquired immunity is an older term, but the meaning is the same. The newly learned immune response is acquired by adapting to the new situation. It has to learn how to fight the invader. Adaptive immunity has to take a look at the new invader, and the mechanisms involved actually take tiny bits of it to a local lymph node. Lymph nodes are those glands that become inflamed and swollen, like those under your jaw and in your neck when you have a sore throat. Your body has lots of them scattered about, sitting quietly waiting for the adaptive immune system to bring them evidence of trouble. Each lymph node has two possible ways of responding to these microscopic and molecular-sized pieces of foreign matter, called antigens. It can develop an antibody (a kind of custom-made protein that circulates in the blood to find, match up with, and neutralize invaders like viruses) or it can train certain types of specialized white blood cells called lymphocytes to recognize, kill, or immobilize the invader. That takes time, sometimes just a few days but often a week or more if the immune system has never “seen” this invader before. The adaptive immune system is always slower to get going than the innate system when something new shows up. Even when it has already learned (from prior exposure) what the invader is, it may take a day or two to get up to speed, but some responses are almost instant. Think about peanut or penicillin allergy, which can onset in minutes with devastating effects. A longer delay is to be expected for some invaders if the original exposure was a long time ago. The innate system is faster because it doesn’t need to process the invading materials again to figure out what the material or foreign invader is. The innate immune system already knows how to react. Whatever the response of the immune systems, the results are always after the fact in acne. There has to be a trigger. A small population of an organism like P. acnes or Malassezia sitting quietly down in the follicular duct, out of reach of the innate and adaptive immune systems, is not by itself enough to cause acne. If it were, we would all have acne, all the time. The same is true of other things found naturally in the follicular units of the folliculopilosebaceous units (FPSUs). Malassezia live on all of us, as do P. acnes and Demodex and many hundreds (no exaggeration!) of other kinds of organisms. If the “acne bacillus” (P. acnes) were the real primary cause of acne vulgaris, all we would need to do is eliminate P. acnes. It has taken over 60 years to realize that killing P. acnes is not enough to clear this disease. We are just now learning that our attempts may have done more harm than good [3, 4]. A tremendous amount of work has been done looking at the cause of inflammation in the acnes and the mechanisms by which inflammation is produced [5]. This has led to the identification of a large number of inflammatory mediators (messengers) present in various stages and forms of the disease. These are triggered by the cytokines, the group of chemicals produced by the inflammatory cells of both immune systems. Some of these molecules are cytokines all by themselves; others trigger additional cytokine and chemokine activity. Cytokines are basically messengers, rather as hormones are messengers. Chemokines are specialized cytokines that tell specific cells, usually lymphocytes, what to do and where to go. Usually the message is that the cell is needed elsewhere to do battle, and to come quickly. But nature likes a balance, so there are other chemokines and cytokines that are inhibitory.
The inflammatory response
7.1 Innate immunity
7.2 Adaptive (acquired) immunity
7.3 Inflammation as the primary acnegen