18. Nonablative Laser Resurfacing
Equipment
Two types of nonablative lasers, and two additional modalities, are commonly used in nonablative resurfacing.
Midinfrared Lasers
Longer wavelength allows deeper penetration into the dermis and partially spares melanin.
Target dermis without a specific chromophore
Not very effective for epidermal signs of photoaging, such as dyschromia
Nd:YAG Laser
1320 nm, long pulses
One of the earliest lasers used for nonablative resurfacing
Early applications did not include a cooling device, and this resulted in a high rate of scarring, hyperpigmentation, and pain.
Newer models include a cryogenic cooling spray, which keeps the epidermis temperature around 40°-48° C, while the dermis is heated to 60°-70° C. 1 , 2
Q-Switched Nd:YAG Laser
1064 nm, very short pulses
Coupled with a cryogenic cooling device
Very effective at treating tatoos 5
Senior Author Tip:
This laser does not see “brown pigment” well so it is an excellent choice for treating tattoos in darker skin types.
Diode Laser
Erbium-Doped Fractional Laser
Fraxel (Solta Medical)
1550 nm
The most frequently used nonablative laser and has multiple applications, such as dyschromia, 8 , 9 fine rhytids, 8 , 9 acne scars, 10 burn scars, 8 , 9 , 11 striae distensae 12
Treatment of dyschromia: Same effectiveness as nonablative, nonfractionated lasers 13 , 14
Treatment of rhytids: More effective than nonfractionated, nonablative lasers, but less effective than ablative fractional or fully ablative lasers 13 , 14
Requires three to six treatments, spaced at 2- to 4-week minimum intervals
Other fractional lasers include the Lux 1540 fractional laser (1540 nm, Cynosure) and the Affirm laser (1320 nm + 1440 nm, Cynosure). 15
Senior Author Tip:
Currently our most frequently used laser is actually a dual hybrid laser 1440 nm/2970 nm firing simultaneously in the same spot. The 1440 nm is less painful yet equally effective to the 1550 nm fractional laser and the 2970 nm adds quicker healing time and greater dermal change.
Visible Light Lasers
Pulsed dye laser
585-595 nm
Of limited use in dark skin types because of high affinity for melanin
Risk of hypopigmentation and hyperpigmentation
Shown to increase the quantity of collagen and elastin in the dermis 16
Photodynamic therapy: Effect can be potentiated by topical application of a photosensitizer, such as 5-aminolevulinic acid. 17
For aging treatment, fluencies used are below those typically used for the treatment of vascular lesions, and pulse width durations are longer than those used to treat port-wine stains to minimize purpura.
Best used for signs of hypervascularity and dyschromia
Most effective laser for port-wine stain treatment
Intense Pulsed Light
Not a laser. Intense polychromatic light including multiple wavelengths from 500-1200 nm. 18
Filters can be added to allow only certain wavelengths, thus targeting specific chromophores.
Of limited use in dark skin types (IV–VI) because of affinity for melanin
Excellent in the treatment of hypervascularity, such as rosacea and telangiectasia 19
Very good in the treatment of dyspigmentation, such as solar lentigines 13
Broadband light (BBL) is a form of IPL and has proven to be effective in genetic transcription to a more youthful genomic expression with multiple frequent treatments at least three times per year for several years 20
Photodynamic therapy: Effect can be potentiated by topical application of a photosensitizer, such as 5-aminolevulinic acid. 21
Radiofrequency
ThermaCool (Solta Medical)
Radiofrequency waves cause collagen denaturation when heated to 55°-62° C, and the amount of collagen in the skin increases over time. 22
Amount of tissue heating and the placement of that heating zone can be controlled by modifying the fluence of the radiofrequency waves and the intensity of the cryogenic cooling spray.
Heat is delivered at high fluence (70–150 J/cm2) for short pulses (<2.3 seconds) (flash heating).
Because radiofrequency does not target melanin, it can be used safely in patients of all skin phenotypes.
Used in patients with mild skin laxity
Does not address underlying structural ptosis
Several studies analyzing the efficacy of monopolar radiofrequency showed measurable improvement in skin laxity.
Can be painful to the patient
Low risk of complications, although multiple reports have described fat atrophy from heat damage to adipose tissue early in the treatment’s evolution. 26 Current treatment protocols greatly minimize or eliminate this risk.
Technique
Anesthesia
Nonablative lasers are not as painful as ablative lasers in general, but can vary depending on the depth; i.e., a deep, nonablative laser treatment could possibly cause more pain than a superficial ablative laser treatment.
Topical anesthesia, typically with EMLA (2.5% prilocaine/2.5% lidocaine) or LMX (4% or 5% lidocaine), is usually sufficient.
It must be applied at least 1 hour before treatment, covered with an occlusive dressing, and wiped off just before treatment.