Chapter 18 Use of the Transtibial Technique to Avoid Posterior Cruciate Ligament and Roof Impingement of an Anterior Cruciate Ligament Graft

Introduction

This chapter discusses the definition, complications, diagnosis, and prevention of posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) and roof impingement, which must be avoided to restore motion and stability in an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstructed knee. Evidence will be presented that the key tunnel in the transtibial technique is the tibial tunnel. Correct placement of the tibial tunnel in the coronal and sagittal planes, and subsequent drilling of the femoral tunnel through the tibial tunnel, avoids PCL and roof impingement, replicates the tension pattern of the intact ACL, and determines the motion and stability of the knee.

The rationale for preventing PCL and roof impingement requires an understanding of the anatomy of the intercondylar notch, especially the wide variations in the cross-sectional relationship between the ACL graft, intact ACL, and PCL. A time-tested and scientifically evaluated surgical technique for placing the tibial and femoral tunnels that consistently prevents PCL and roof impingement is presented. This simple and accurate technique relies on widening the notch by performing a wallplasty and using a tibial guide that controls the angle of the tibial tunnel in the coronal plane and registers the intercondylar roof with the knee in extension in the sagittal plane. In the coronal plane, the tibial guide prevents PCL impingement by customizing the placement of the guidewire at 60 to 65 degrees with respect to the medial joint line of the tibia and placing the lateral edge of the tibial tunnel through the tip of the lateral tibial spine. In the sagittal plane, the tibial guide prevents roof impingement by placing the guidewire 5 to 6 mm posterior and parallel to the intercondylar roof with the knee in maximal hyperextension.

Definition, Complications, and Diagnosis of Posterior Cruciate Ligament Impingement

PCL impingement occurs when the ACL graft wraps around the PCL as the knee is flexed. Impingement of the ACL graft around the PCL causes a tension rise in flexion that either limits flexion or stretches the ACL graft, resulting in anterior instability. Not widening the notch and malplacement of the ACL graft in the coronal plane cause PCL impingement in the transtibial technique.¹^–³

PCL impingement can be suspected if bone was not removed from the lateral femoral condyle (i.e., a wallplasty) until the space between the PCL and lateral femoral condyle exceeded the width of the ACL graft by 1 mm. An anteroposterior (AP) radiograph is diagnostic of PCL impingement when the tibial tunnel is at an angle greater than 70 degrees with respect to the medial joint line or when the lateral edge of the tibial tunnel is medial to the apex of the lateral tibial spine ² (Fig. 18-1). Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with three-dimensional (3D) reconstruction is diagnostic of PCL impingement when there is no space between the ACL graft and PCL or when the ACL graft does not run straight and is deformed by the PCL.¹ Arthroscopy is diagnostic of PCL impingement when there is no space between the ACL graft and PCL at the apex of the notch and when the ACL graft is slack and bows laterally with the knee in 30 degrees of flexion.³ Surgeons who avoid PCL impingement will find that their patients have better knee flexion and better anterior and rotatory stability.^1,²

Fig. 18-1 The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) grafts in both of these knees suffered from posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) impingement. The surgical error in the left radiograph was that the tibial tunnel was placed too vertical at 85 degrees, which placed the femoral tunnel at the apex of the notch. The tibial tunnel should have been placed at 65 degrees with respect to the medial joint line of the tibia. However, placing the tibial tunnel at 65 degrees does not guarantee that the ACL graft is placed without PCL impingement. The surgical error in the right radiograph is that the notch was not widened with a wallplasty, and the tibial tunnel and femoral tunnel were placed too medial, such that the femoral tunnel was at the apex of the notch. The lateral edge of the tibial tunnel should pass through the tip of the lateral spine, not through the tip of the medial spine.

Definition, Complications, and Diagnosis of Roof Impingement

Roof impingement occurs when the intercondylar roof contacts the ACL graft before the knee reaches full extension. Impingement of the ACL graft against the intercondylar roof causes either a loss of extension or a stretching out of the graft from abrasion, resulting in anterior instability. The cause of roof impingement is malplacement of the ACL graft in the sagittal plane. Placing the tibial tunnel anterior to the intercondylar roof with the knee in maximal extension causes roof impingement.⁴^–⁷

A lateral radiograph of the knee in maximal extension is diagnostic of roof impingement when the tibial tunnel is anterior to the intercondylar roof (Fig. 18-2). The lateral radiograph is less helpful in evaluating a bone–patellar tendon–bone graft than a soft tissue graft because the bone plug may obscure the wall and orientation of the tibial tunnel and because the tendon does not fill the bone tunnel.⁷ An MRI is diagnostic of roof impingement when the pathognomonic regionalized signal increase occurs in the graft, which is confined to the distal two-thirds of the ligament within the intercondylar notch. The portion of the ACL graft in the tibial and femoral tunnel and the portion of the graft that exits the femoral tunnel retain a low signal, which is identical to the PCL and patellar tendon.⁸^–¹⁰ Arthroscopy is diagnostic of roof impingement when the ACL graft is frayed or a fibrous nodule is formed at the entrance of the tibial tunnel into the notch.¹¹ Surgeons who avoid roof impingement will find that their patients have better knee extension and stability.^7,¹²

Fig. 18-2 The bone–patella–bone graft failed from roof impingement (left radiograph). The surgical error was that the tibial tunnel was placed anterior to the intercondylar roof with the knee in full extension. The graft failed due to abrasion and stretch-out. The tibial tunnel was moved more posterior in the revision with a hamstring anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) graft (right radiograph). The hamstring graft was pushed more posterior by a bone graft placed along the anterior edge of the tunnel (asterisk). The tibial tunnel should be placed posterior to the intercondylar roof with the knee in maximal extension.

The Tibial Tunnel: The Key Tunnel in the Transtibial Technique

The advantage of the transtibial technique is that when the notch is widened and the tibial tunnel is placed correctly in the coronal and sagittal plane, the correct placement of the femoral tunnel is automatic. The reason for this is that the position of the over-the-top femoral aimer and the position of the reamer are both controlled by the tibial tunnel.³ If the notch is not widened and the tibial tunnel is placed incorrectly in either the coronal or sagittal plane, then the femoral tunnel will be placed incorrectly and the patient will suffer from motion loss or instability.^1,^2,⁷

The feasibility of the transtibial technique to replicate the tension pattern of the intact ACL was determined by a cadaveric study that analyzed the effect of varying the angle of the tibial tunnel (and femoral tunnel) in the coronal plane on the tension pattern of the ACL graft (Fig. 18-3). Drilling the tibial tunnel at an angle of 60 degrees in the coronal plane placed the ACL graft far down the side wall of the notch away from the PCL, and the tension in the graft matched the intact ACL. Drilling the tibial tunnel at 70 and 80 degrees placed the ACL graft near the apex of the notch and the PCL, and the tension increase in the ACL graft with knee flexion was subsequently abolished by incremental excision of 2 to 6 mm of the lateral edge of the PCL. Therefore, the cause of the abnormal tension rise in flexion is the premature mechanical impingement of the ACL graft on the PCL during flexion and is avoided by placing the tibial tunnel at an angle less than 70 degrees.³

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue