The Spanish Model of Organ Donation and Transplantation



Fig. 26.1
Evolution of transplantation activities in Spain, in terms of number of solid organ transplant procedures (absolute numbers). Between the years 1989–2014.





A316419_1_En_26_Fig2_HTML.gif


Fig. 26.2
Evolution of transplantation activities in Spain, in terms of number of solid organ transplant procedures (absolute numbers). Between the years 1989–2014.



26.2 The Spanish Model on Organ Donationand Transplantation


The measures composing the Spanish Model were adopted after the Spanish National Transplant Organization (Organización Nacional de Trasplantes—ONT) was created in 1989. ONT was conceived as a technical agency dependent on the Ministry of Health and in charge of the oversight of all donation and transplantation activities in the country. Dependency on the Ministry of Health was representative of transplantation being placed on the political agenda—an anticipated response to the call for national accountability that the WHO would launch almost 20 years later. Results of the Spanish Model derive from the basic principle of having an appropriate organization centered around the process of deceased donation, particularly around the process of donation after brain death (DBD), representing 90–95 % of the deceased donation activity in the country as a whole.




Table 26.1
Main elements of the Spanish model of organ donation and transplantation




















Transplant coordination network on three levels: National—ONT-, regional, hospital

Special profile of transplant coordinators

Central office—ONT—as a supporting agency. Not just an organ sharing-allocation agency

Quality assurance program in the deceased donation process

Great effort in professional training

Close attention to the mass media with a special communication policy

Hospital reimbursement for donation and transplantation activities

Measures implemented in Spain were based on an appropriate background from the health-care, technical and legal point of view. The Spanish health-care system is a public one with universal coverage for the population, entailing that transplantation is included in the public health-care portfolio and every citizen will have access to that therapy if needed. Technically, the country was able to count on extraordinarily prepared, enthusiastic, innovative and motivated transplant teams from the very beginning. The Spanish Transplantation Law was first enacted in 1979, containing the basic elements of any occidental transplantation law .6 An opting-out system for consent to donation has been in place since then in Spain. It is quite frequent that the Spanish success is attributed to this legal system of consent. However, the presumed consent policy is not strictly applied in practice; relatives are always approached and have the final veto.7 From a political point of view, the Spanish donation and transplantation system had to accommodate to the reality of political competencies having been transferred to the 17 different autonomous regions of Spain: any national initiative in the field ought to be reached by inter-regional consensus. The main elements of the Spanish Model are listed in Table 26.1 and are described in detail below.8


26.2.1 Transplant Coordination Network on Three Levels


The coordination of donation activities has been conceived and structured on three different, but interrelated levels: national, regional and hospital. The national level is represented by ONT and the regional level by 17 regional transplant coordination offices, one per autonomous region. These first two levels, both being dependent on the national and regional health-care authorities respectively, act as an interface between the technical and the political strata and in full support of the effective realization of the process of donation from the deceased. Any national decision on donation and transplantation activities is made in agreement with the National Transplant Committee of the Health Interterritorial Council, composed of ONT as chair and the 17 regional coordinators. The hospital level of coordination is represented by a network of hospitals officially authorized for handling procurement activities, in direct charge of developing the deceased donation process in an efficient way. This network evolved from less than 20 hospitals in 1989 to 118 in 1992, a rapid evolution which reflects the important efforts performed by the system and the political support received already in its very first years. The network has kept increasing with 181 hospitals being involved in 2012.


26.2.2 In-Hospital Transplant Coordination Teams


A transplant coordination team is appointed at each procurement hospital, constituting a team that is responsible for developing a proactive donor detection program and effectively converting potential into actual donors. The transplant coordinators (TCs) in Spain, particularly the leaders of the transplant coordination teams, have a unique profile conceived to facilitate the early identification and referral of possible or potential organ donors, the critical phase of the process of deceased donation. TCs are in-house professionals, part of the staff of the procurement hospital that is involved, rather than having professionals that are located outside of the hospitals and that would have to be contacted upon the identification of a potential donor. TCs are nominated by and report to the medical board of the hospital, hence not being dependent on the head of the transplantation teams. Most of the TCs are part-time dedicated to donation activities, which allows them to be appointed even at hospitals with a low deceased donor potential. The part-time dedication also permits these professionals to leave the coordination tasks and return to and be fully dedicated to their original activities when appropriate. Notably, the majority of the leaders of the transplant coordination teams in Spain are critical care physicians.TCs thus develop their daily activity directly at those units where 12.4 % of deaths occur in persons with a clinical condition consistent with brain death .9


26.2.3 Central Office—ONT—as a Supporting Agency


ONT acts as a supporting agency to the network of procurement hospitals in addition to being in charge of organ sharing and allocation in the country, according to predefined and agreed-upon medical criteria. ONT’s support and that provided by some regional offices is especially important for small hospitals, which frequently do not have the capability of developing the whole process of deceased donation on their own.


26.2.4 Quality Assurance Program in the Deceased Donation Process


The Quality Assurance Program in the Deceased Donation Process has become an essential tool in the consolidation of the system.10 So far focused on DBD, the program aims at assessing and monitoring the potential of deceased organ donation, evaluating performance and identifying key areas for improvement in the realization of the deceased donation process. Already in place for more than 10 years, the program is based on a continuous and systematic review of the clinical charts of all patients dying at critical care units in the procurement hospitals. The program includes an internal audit performed by TCs locally that allows the building up of specific performance reference indicators. This activity is complemented by external audits carried out by expert TCs belonging to a region different to the one to which the evaluated hospital belongs. External audits are performed under the request of regional TCs and provide a unique opportunity for sharing practices and experiences and thus identifying possible actions for improvement in the form of recommendations targeted at the transplant coordination team and the hospital managers.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Aug 1, 2017 | Posted by in General Surgery | Comments Off on The Spanish Model of Organ Donation and Transplantation

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access