© Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2017
Anthony A. Gaspari, Stephen K. Tyring and Daniel H. Kaplan (eds.)Clinical and Basic Immunodermatology10.1007/978-3-319-29785-9_3636. Epidermolysis Bullosa Acquisita
(1)
Department of Dermatology, LAC & USC Medical Center, Stanford Hospital, Los Angeles, CA, USA
(2)
Department of Dermatology, USA Norris Cancer Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA
(3)
Department of Dermatology, USA Norris Cancer Center, 1441 East Lake Avenue, Topping Tower #3405, Los Angeles, CA 90033, USA
Abstract
In 1895, two cases of a blistering disease with adult onset and features highly reminiscent of hereditary dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa (EB) were reported by Elliott. These clinical features included skin fragility, erosions, blisters, and a healing response characterized by scarring and the formation of milial cysts.
Keywords
Epidermolysis bullosa acquisitaEBAAutoimmune diseaseBlistersSkin diseasePorphyria cutanea tardaPCTBullous pemphigoidBPCicatricial pemphigoidCPImmunoelectron MicroscopyIMAnti–tumor necrosis factor-aTNF-aPathogenesisKey Points
Epidermolysis bullosa acquisita (EBA) is an autoimmune, blistering skin condition, in which there is an autoantibody to type VII collagen, a component of the anchoring fibril complex of the basement membrane zone.
There are a number of clinical presentations of this disease: the classic porphyria cutanea tarda (PCT)-like, noninflammatory mechanobullous disease; the bullous pemphigoid (BP) presentation of widespread inflammatory blisters; the cicatricial pemphigoid (CP)–like presentation with mucous membrane involvement; the Brunsting- Perry–like presentation (disease localized to the head and neck area); and the immunoglobulin A (IgA) bullous dermatosis–like presentation (inflammatory presentation with a neutrophil- rich infiltrate).
Complications of EBA include: esophageal strictures, loss of nails, scarring, and contractures of the hands.
Epidermolysis bullosa acquisita may be associated with underlying diseases such as inflammatory bowel disease, systemic lupus erythematosus, amyloidosis, and other inflammatory and autoimmune conditions.
Clinical presentation and histological findings are used to confirm this diagnosis. Indirect and direct immunofluorescence mapping studies on NaCl split skin can facilitate distinguishing EBA from bullous pemphigoid. Western blotting confirms that the sera from EBA patients bind to a 290-kd autoantigen (type VII collagen).
Epidermolysis bullosa acquisita can be challenging to treat. Colchicine and systemic glucocorticosteroids alone or in combination with cytotoxic drugs or cyclosporine have been used to treat severe disease. Recently, rituximab has shown promising results as a treatment option for EBA.
In 1895, two cases of a blistering disease with adult onset and features highly reminiscent of hereditary dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa (EB) were reported by Elliott [1]. These clinical features included skin fragility, erosions, blisters, and a healing response characterized by scarring and the formation of milial cysts.
In the early 1970s, Roenigk et al. [2] summarized the epidermolysis bullosa acquisita (EBA) world literature, reported three new cases, and suggested the first diagnostic criteria: (1) a negative family and personal history for a previous blistering disorder, (2) an adult onset of the eruption, (3) spontaneous or trauma-induced blisters that resemble those of hereditary dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa, and (4) the exclusion of all other bullous diseases.
Kushniruk [3], Gibbs and Minus [4], and Nieboer et al. [5] showed that patients with EBA had immunoglobulin G (IgG) deposits at the dermal– epidermal junction identical to patients with bullous pemphigoid (BP). However, Nieboer et al. and Yaoita et al.[6] showed that the IgG deposits in EBA were within and below the lamina densa area of the basement membrane zone (BMZ), whereas BP immune deposits are within hemidesmosomes and high in the lamina lucida. Distinguishing EBA from the BP group is important because the clinical, pathologic, and immunologic presentations of EBA may be identical to BP and cicatricial pemphigoid (CP) but treatments may vary (see below) [7–12].
Clinical Findings
As noted above, the cutaneous lesions of EBA can be quite varied and can mimic other types of acquired autoimmune bullous diseases. The common denominator for patients with EBA is autoimmunity to type VII (anchoring fibril) collagen. Although the clinical spectrum of EBA is still being defined, there are at least five clinical presentations: (1) a classic presentation, (2) a BP-like presentation, (3) a CP-like presentation, (4) a presentation reminiscent of Brunsting- Perry pemphigoid with scarring lesions and a predominant head and neck distribution, and (5) a presentation reminiscent of linear IgA bullous dermatosis or chronic bullous disease of childhood [11–14].
Classic Presentation
This disease classically presents with non-inflammatory bullous lesions with an acral distribution that heals with scars and milia formation. When clinically mild, this form of EBA is reminiscent of porphyria cutanea tarda (PCT). However, when clinically severe, EBA will resemble the hereditary form of recessive dystrophic EB. The classic form of EBA is thus a mechanobullous disease marked by skin fragility. These patients have erosions, tense blisters within non-inflamed skin, and scars over trauma-prone surfaces such as the backs of the hands, knuckles, elbows, knees, sacral area, and toes. Some blisters may be hemorrhagic or develop scales, crusts, or erosions. The lesions heal with scarring and frequently form pearl-like milia cysts within the scarred areas. Additionally, a scarring alopecia and some degree of nail dystrophy may be seen. Although this presentation may be reminiscent of PCT, these patients do not have other hallmarks of PCT such as hirsutism, a photodistribution of the eruption, or scleroderma-like changes. Additional, their urinary porphyrins are within normal limits.
Although the disease is usually not as severe as that of patients with hereditary forms of recessive dystrophic EB, EBA patients with the classic form of the disease may have many of the same sequelae such as scarring, loss of scalp hair, loss of nails, fibrosis of the hands and fingers, and esophageal stenosis [15–28].
Bullous Pemphigoid-Like Presentation
A second clinical presentation of EBA is of a wide- spread, inflammatory vesiculobullous eruption involving the trunk, central body, skin folds, and extremities [7]. These tense bullous lesions are surrounded by inflamed or even urticarial skin. Large areas of skin may be without any blisters but with erythematous and urticarial plaques. These patients often complain of pruritus and do not demonstrate prominent skin fragility, scarring, or milia formation. This clinical constellation is more reminiscent of BP than of a mechanobullous disorder. Like BP, the distribution of the lesions may show an accentuation within flexural areas and skin folds. About 25 % of patients with EBA may present with a BP-like clinical appearance.
Cicatricial Pemphigoid-Like Presentation
Both the classic and BP-like forms of EBA may have involvement of mucosal surfaces. However, EBA also may present with such predominant mucosal involvement that the clinical appearance is reminiscent of CP [8]. These patients usually have erosions and scars on the mucosal membrane of the mouth, upper esophagus, conjunctiva, anus, or vagina with or without similar lesions on the glabrous skin. The clinical phenotype of EBA that is reminiscent of pure CP occurs in fewer than 10 % of all EBA cases.
Brunsting-Perry Pemphigoid-Like Presentation
Brunsting-Perry pemphigoid is a chronic recurrent vesiculobullous eruption localized to the head and neck and characterized by residual scars, subepidermal bullae, IgG deposits at the dermal–epidermal junction, and minimal or no mucosal involvement. The antigentic target for the IgG autoantibodies has yet to be defined; however, a patient reported with these findings had IgG autoantibodies directed against anchoring fibrils below the lamina densa [12]. It appears that EBA patients may present with a clinical phenotype similar to Brunsting-Perry pemphigoid.
Linear Immunoglobulin A Bullous Dermatosis-Like Presentation
This form of EBA manifests as a subepidermal bullous eruption with a neutrophilic infiltrate and linear IgA deposits at the BMZ when viewed by direct immunofluorescence (DIF). Clinically, it may resemble linear IgA bullous dermatosis (LABD), dermatitis herpetiformis, or chronic bullous disease of childhood (CBDC), and may feature tense vesicles arranged in an annular fashion with or without involvement of mucous membranes [29–34]. The autoantibodies are usually IgA, IgG, or both. Some clinicians regard these patients as having purely LABD [31], whereas others regard them as having a subset of EBA [32].
Childhood EBA
Childhood EBA is a rare disease with a variable presentation. Out of 14 patients reviewed, 5 presented with an LABD-like disease, another 5 presented with BP-like disease, and 4 presented with the classical manifestations [34]. Mucosal involvement is frequent in childhood EBA. The overall prognosis is more favorable than for adults with EBA [30, 34].
Additional Clinical Findings
In addition to the protean clinical manifestations of EBA, patients may suffer from a number of associated clinical problems that add to the morbidity of the disease. These include oral erosions, esophageal strictures, nail loss, milia formation, scarring, and a degree fibrosis of the hands. These are all associated clinical conditions that are shared (albeit usually milder) with hereditary dystropic EB.
Associated Systemic Diseases
Epidermolysis bullosa acquisita has been linked to several systemic diseases. Most commonly, inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) occurs in 20–30 % of all EBA patients. Patients with IBD, particularly Crohn’s disease, have circulating antibodies to collagen 7 (C7) in approximately 70 % of cases [35, 37]. Recently, Ishii et al. have shown that injection of rabbit anti-murine C7 IgG (passive acquisition of EBA) or immunization with a fragment of murine C7 (active acquisition of EBA) not only produced cutaneous symptoms of EBA but also resulted in autoantibody deposition in the gastrointestinal tract with resultant blister formation [36, 38]. These findings in a mice model suggest that the correlation between IBD and EBA is more direct than previous thought. In addition to its relationship with IBD, anecdotal reports suggest that EBA may have other associated systemic diseases including systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), amyloidosis, thyroiditis, multiple endocrinopathy syndrome, rheumatoid arthritis, pulmonary fibrosis, chronic lymphocytic leukemia, thymoma, diabetes, and other diseases in which an autoimmune pathogenesis has been implicated [37, 38].
Clinical Evaluation
Histopathology
Histopathology of an EBA lesion shows a subepidermal blister. In the classic mechanobullous presentation of EBA, there is fibrin in the blister cavity and an overall paucity of associated inflammatory cells within the blister cavity and dermis. Fibrosis and scaring may also be present in the underlying dermis. In the BP-like EBA presentation, the histopathology shows a more significant dermal inflammatory infiltrate of lymphocytes, macrophages, neutrophils, and eosinophils. In the IgA pemphigoid-like EBA form, there is often a predominance of neutrophils.
Direct Immunofluorescence
Krushnick et al. [3], Gibbs and Minor [4], Nieboer et al. [5], and Yaoita et al. [6] have shown that a positive direct immunofluorescence (DIF) is necessary for the diagnosis of EBA. Immunoglobulin G (IgG) and, to a lesser extent C3, deposits are present at the dermal–epidermal junction by DIF from a perilesional biopsy. However, the immunodeposits are almost identical in pattern to those seen in bullous pemphigoid. EBA may have stronger IgG deposition, while BP may have strong C3 deposition. Therefore, performing salt-split skin (SSS) DIF and SSS indirect immunofluorescence (IIF) are necessary to distinguish EBA from the pemphigoid group of disorders. To perform the SSS technique, perilesional skin showing immunodeposits during routine DIF is incubated in 1 mol/L cold NaCl for 72 h. The procedure fractures the dermal–epidermal junction through the lamina lucida of the basement membrane zone. This places the bullous pemphigoid autoantigens associated with the hemidesmosome (i.e., BPAg 1 and BPAg 2, also known as type XVII collagen) on the epidermal roof of the separation [36–45]. The EBA antigen, type VII collagen, remains with the dermal floor [47]. The immunoreactants (usually IgG and C3) are again incubated with the tissue. If the patient has EBA, the immune deposits are detected on the dermal side of the separation.
Indirect Immunofluorescence
Many, but not all, EBA patients have an anti–BMZ IgG autoantibody circulating in their blood that can be detected by IIF. The EBA serum autoantibodies label frozen sections of human skin or monkey esophagus, producing a crisp linear fluorescent staining at the dermal–epidermal junction of the frozen sections after incubation with anti-IgG fluorescent-labeled antibodies. As with the routine DIF procedure, one cannot distinguish EBA from the pemphigoid group of diseases without doing salt-split IIF, which is always done on human skin substrate. Human skin is incubated in 1 mol/L NaCl, and the dermal–epidermal junction fractures cleanly through the lamina lucida zone, placing the BP antigens on the epidermal roof and the EBA antigen (type VII anchoring fibril collagen) on the dermal floor [41]. Salt-split skin substrate can be used to distinguish EBA and BP sera [42]. If the serum antibody is IgG and labels the epidermal roof, the patient does not have EBA, and BP should be considered. If, on the other hand, the antibody labels the dermal side of the separation, the patient usually has either EBA or bullous SLE. The latter can be ruled out by other serology and clinical criteria.
Rare Diseases that Give Dermal Staining by Salt-Split Immunofluorescence
It was thought that only EBA and bullous SLE show dermal staining of the salt-split skin on IIF or DIF. In recent years, other very rare autoimmune diseases have been shown to have IgG deposits in the lower lamina lucida space that map to the dermal side when the skin substrate is fractured by SSS technique. These diseases include anti-laminin 5 cicatricial pemphigoid [43], a BP-like disease in which the patients have autoantibodies to a 105- kd lamina lucida glycoprotein that is unrelated to laminin-5 [44], a newly discovered disease reported by Ghohestani and colleagues [46], with IgG autoantibodies directed against the α5 chain of type IV (lamina densa) collagen in association with renal failure, and another BP-like disease called protein 200 pemphigoid in which the autoantigen is a 200-kd glycoprotein in the lower part of the lamina lucida.
Electron Microscopy
Electron microscopy (EM) shows that the dermal–epidermal separation in an EBA lesion is associated with a paucity of normal anchoring fibrils and an amorphous, electron dense band beneath the lamina densa due to the IgG deposits over the anchoring fibrils [9]. Despite the sublamina densa deposits, EBA blisters frequently separate above the immune deposits within the lamina lucida [39].
Immunoelectron Microscopy
Immunoelectron microscopy (IEM) localizes the EBA IgG autoantibody deposits in the BMZ to within and below the lamina densa, the location of the anchoring fibrils. Immunoelectron microscopy showing these sublamina densa IgG deposits is the gold standard for the diagnosis, as first demonstrated by Nieboer et al. [13] and Yaoita et al. [6] This localization is distinct from BP IgG deposits which are localized to the hemidesmosomes of the basal keratinocytes and the IgG autoantibody deposits in CP and are confined to the lower lamina lucida.
Western Immunoblotting
Antibodies in EBA sera bind to a 290-kd band in Western blots of human skin basement membrane proteins containing type VII collagen, whereas sera from other primary blistering diseases do not [13].
This band corresponds to the alpha-chain of type VII collagen. Often a second band of 145 kd will be labeled with EBA antibodies. This band is the amino-terminal globular NC1 domain of the type VII collagen alpha-chain that is rich in carbohydrate and contains the antigenic epitopes of EBA autoantibodies, bullous SLE autoantibodies, and monoclonal antibodies against type VII collagen [13, 48].
Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay
Now that purified, recombinant, human, type VII collagen is readily available, an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the diagnosis of EBA has been developed by Chen et al. [24, 49]. It has proven to be more sensitive for detecting anti-COL7 EBA autoantibodies in the sera of patients than either IIF or Western blotting analysis. ELISA is performed quickly and easily with a very high sensitivity in determining which circulating autoantibodies are present.
Pathogenesis
Although EBA does not have a mendelian pattern of inheritance, African-American EBA patients in the Southeastern part of the United States have a high incidence of the human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-DR2 phenotype. The calculated relative risk for EBA in HLA-DR2+ individuals is 13.1 in these patients [27]. It is thought that, although it is not the primary cause, these patients have an immune profile that makes them susceptible to the disease.
While the etiology of EBA is unknown, it appears that when IgG autoantibodies bind to the patient’s anchoring fibrils, a paucity of normal anchoring fibrils at the BMZ develops, and this is associated with poor dermal–epidermal adherence. This is exactly the same problem as hereditary dystrophic forms of EB due to a defect in the gene that encodes for type VII collagen.
Epidermolysis bullosa acquisita likely has an autoimmune etiology. Direct immunofluorescence of perilesional skin biopsies from EBA patients reveals IgG deposits at the dermal–epidermal junction [3–6]. The EBA antibodies bind to type VII collagen within anchoring fibrils [13, 14], structures that emanate perpendicularly from the BMZ and attach to the papillary dermis. This process results in decreased anchoring fibrils, but the pathway leading to this reduction is unknown. Type VII collagen has an affinity for fibronectin, a large glycoprotein in the papillary dermis and this interaction between the two may play a role in anchoring the basement membrane [22]. It is conceivable that EBA autoantibodies binding to type VII collagen interrupt the interaction between type VII collagen and fibronectin and a separation ensues.