Acknowledging the Clinical Heterogeneity of Lupus Erythematosus


Clinical criteria

1. Acute cutaneous lupus

Including lupus malar rash (do not count if malar discoid)

 Bullous lupus

 Toxic epidermal necrolysis variant of SLE

 Maculopapular lupus rash

 Photosensitive lupus rash in the absence of dermatomyositis

 Or subacute cutaneous lupus

 Nonindurated psoriasiform and/or annular polycyclic lesions that resolve without scarring, although occasionally with postinflammatory dyspigmentation or telangiectasias

2. Chronic cutaneous lupus

Including classical discoid rash

 Localized (above the neck)

 Generalized (above and below the neck)

 Hypertrophic (verrucous) lupus

 Lupus panniculitis (profundus)

 Mucosal lupus

 Lupus erythematosus tumidus

 Chilblain lupus

 Discoid lupus/lichen planus overlap

3. Oral ulcers

Palate, buccal, tongue, or nasal ulcers

 In the absence of other causes, such as vasculitis, Behcet’s disease, infection (herpes), inflammatory bowel disease, reactive arthritis, and acidic foods

4. Nonscarring alopecia

(Diffused thinning or hair fragility with visible broken hairs)

 In the absence of other causes such as alopecia areata, drugs, iron deficiency, and androgenic alopecia

5. Synovitis

Involving two or more joints, characterized by swelling or effusion or tenderness in two or more joints and 30 min or more of morning stiffness

6. Serositis

Typical pleurisy for more than 1 day

 Or pleural effusions

 Or pleural rub

Typical pericardial pain (pain with recumbency improved by sitting forward) for more than 1 day

 Or pericardial effusion

 Or pericardial rub

 Or pericarditis by EKG

 In the absence of other causes, such as infection, uremia, and Dressler’s pericarditis

7. Renal

Urine protein/creatinine (or 24 h urine protein) representing 500 mg of protein/24 h

Or

Red blood cell casts

8. Neurologic

Seizures, psychosis mononeuritis multiplex

 In the absence of other known causes such as primary vasculitis

Myelitis, peripheral or cranial neuropathy

 In the absence of other known causes such as primary vasculitis, infection, and diabetes mellitus

Acute confusional state

 In the absence of other causes, including toxic-metabolic, uremia, drugs

9. Hemolytic anemia
 
10. Leukopenia or lymphopenia

Leukopenia (<4,000/mm3 at least once)

 In the absence of other known causes such as Felty’s syndrome, drugs, and portal hypertension

 Or

 Lymphopenia (<1,000/mm3 at least once) in the absence of other known causes such as corticosteroids, drugs, and infection

11. Thrombocytopenia

(<100,000/mm3) at least once

 In the absence of other known causes such as drugs, portal hypertension, and TTP

Immunological criteria

1. ANA

Positive, above laboratory reference range

2. Anti-dsDNA

Positive, above laboratory reference range, except ELISA: twice above laboratory

 Reference range

3. Anti-Sm

Positive

4. Antiphospholipid antibody

Any of the following lupus anticoagulant:

 False-positive RPR

 Medium- or high-titer anticardiolipin (IgA, IgG, or IgM)

 Anti-β2 glycoprotein I (IgA, IgG or IgM)

5. Low complement

Low C3

Low C4

Low CH50

6. Direct Coombs test

Positive, in the absence of hemolytic anemia


Modified from Petri et al. [4]

Classify a patient as having SLE if the patient satisfies four of the criteria listed in the table, including at least one clinical criterion and one immunologic criterion, or the patient has a biopsy-proven nephritis compatible with SLE and with ANA or anti-dsDNA antibodies



The Revised Cutaneous Lupus Erythematosus Disease Area and Severity Index (RCLASI) has specifically been developed to assess disease activity and damage in CLE. This disease activity index focuses on LE skin parameters, including scaling, hypertrophy, dyspigmentation, edema, infiltration, and subcutaneous nodules [1].



9.2 The Spectrum of Cutaneous LE


As indicated above, the spectrum of skin lesions which may appear in the context of LE is wide. To make a complex topic even more complicated, these LE-associated skin lesions are distinguished in two major groups: “LE-specific” and “LE-nonspecific” lesions. The LE-specific lesions encompass all the specific dermatological subsets of LE and are clinically subdivided into four different subtypes (acute LE/ACLE, subacute cutaneous LE/SCLE, intermediate cutaneous LE/ICLE, and chronic cutaneous CLE). Typical clinical examples for these CLE subsets are depicted in Fig. 9.1. Skin lesions typically associated with autoimmune diseases albeit not LE-specific are, amongst others, vasculitis, livedo racemosa, calcinosis cutis, and skin ulcers [1].

A313839_1_En_9_Fig1_HTML.gif


Fig. 9.1
The clinical heterogeneity of cutaneous lupus erythematosus skin lesions. Chronic discoid LE: (a) discoid erythrosquamous plaques in the face; (b) subacute cutaneous LE: annular maculae at the back; (c) chilblain LE: erythematous maculae and nodules of the hands; (d) bullous LE (vesicles and small bullae in sun-exposed skin)

As detailed in Table 9.2, two complementary strategies can be used to classify the different specific subsets of CLE: (1) a clinical classification, focusing on the different dynamics of the CLE subsets, and (2) a histological classification, which is based on the typical histological picture and the anatomical structures involved. The typical clinical and histological findings of the most common CLE subtypes are summarized in Table 9.3.


Table 9.2
Clinical and histological classification of CLE





































Clinical classification of CLE modified from Kuhn and Landmann [1]

CLE
 

Acute CLE (ACLE)

Localized form

Generalized form

Bullous LE

Subacute CLE (SCLE)

Annular form

Papulosquamous form

Intermediate CLE (ICLE)

Lupus erythematosus tumidus (LET)

Chronic CLE (CCLE)

Discoid lupus erythematosus (DLE)

 Localized form

 Disseminated form

Lupus erythematosus profundus (LEP; LE panniculitis)

Chilblain lupus erythematosus (CHLE)


































Histological classification of CLE:

Histological pattern

LE subtype

Dermoepidermal LE

Acute LE

Subacute LE

Chronic discoid LE

Bullous LE

Chilblain LE

Dermal LE

LE tumidus

Jessner’s lymphocytic infiltration (JLI)

Reticular erythematous mucinosis (REM)

Papular mucinosis

Hypodermal LE

LE panniculitis (LE profundus)



Table 9.3
Clinical and histological findings of the most common CLE subtypes


























































































 
Clinical

Histological

Acute CLE (ACLE)

Butterfly rash

Edema and only mild lesional inflammation with a cell-poor interface dermatitis

Erythema in sun-exposed skin

Neutrophils within the infiltrate

Close association to SLE

ANA >90 % positive

Anti-dsDNA, anti-RNP, and anti-Sm often positive

Subacute cutaneous LE (SCLE)

Annular, gyrated, or plaque-like erythrosquamous lesions in sun-exposed skin, but not the face

Cell-poor IFD with superficial lymphoid infiltrate

ANA 60–80 % positive

Atrophic epidermal layer

Anti-SSA/Ro and anti-SSB/La often positive

Mucin deposits in upper dermis

LE tumidus (LET)

Erythematous, pad-like, infiltrated lesions in sun-exposed skin (including the face)

Dense, patch-like, perivascular, and perifollicular lymphoid infiltrate (superficial and deep)

No scaling

Large amounts of mucin within the dermal layer

ANA 10–30 % positive

Clusters of CD123-positive pDCs

Anti-SSA/Ro and anti-SSB/La negative

Chronic discoid LE (CDLE)

Scarring, discoid, and erythrosquamous lesions

Dense, patch-like, perivascular, and perifollicular lymphoid infiltrate (superficial and deep)

Predilection sites: capillitium and face

Cell-rich IFD, involvement of the follicular epithelium and follicular hyperkeratosis

Positive tin-tack sign

Broadened basement membrane

ANA 10–30 % positive

Lots of mucin within the dermis

LE profundus (LEP)

Early: subcutaneous nodules and indurations

Early: lobular panniculitis with numerous lymphocytes and pDCs

Late: fat-tissue atrophy and skin retraction

Late: necrosis, fibrosis, and macrophages

Predilection sites: gluteal region, thigh, upper arms, and face

Mucin deposits in the subcutis

ANA ~75 % positive

Polyclonal TCR rearrangement (DD: cytotoxic T-cell lymphoma)

Chilblain LE (ChLE)

Livid and painful with erythemata and indurations and nodules of fingers and toes

Dense, perivascular lymphoid infiltrates within the dermis

Special subset: familial ChLE with mutation on TREX1 gene

Fibrin deposits within small dermal vessels

Sometimes additional typical findings of other CLE subsets (IFD, mucin)

Bullous LE

Small vesicles on erythematous skin in sun-exposed skin areas

Subepidermal blisters with neutrophils

Close association to SLE

Direct immunofluorescence: linear deposits of IgG, IgM, IgA, and C3

Anti-collagen VII positive


9.2.1 Acute CLE (ACLE)


Acute courses of CLE clinically present with plane redness in sun-exposed skin areas, particularly in the face, décolleté, and extensor sides of the arms. The most characteristic clinical sign is the butterfly rash, a symmetric, circumscribed, aliform erythema on both cheeks. This CLE subset shows a close association to SLE in younger female patients and may be accompanied by fever, myalgia, fatigue, and involvement of internal organ systems. In the peripheral blood, often high-titer antinuclear antibodies with SLE-typical specificity (e.g., anti-dsDNA, anti-Sm) are detectable. In contrast to the impressive clinical picture, the histological changes may be discrete. The slides show a mild edema with only minor mucin deposits. However, some neutrophils may accompany the dermal and junctional inflammatory infiltrate. These are rarely found in other CLE subsets and may be indicative for ACLE [5].


9.2.2 Bullous CLE (BLE)


The BLE is a very rare subset of ACLE which presents clinically with confluating small vesicles on erythematous skin in sun-exposed skin areas. Circulating anti-collagen VII antibodies, which target structures in the basement membrane, are typically found in the peripheral blood of the patients affected. Histologically, skin lesions show a subepidermal blister (effect of the anti-collagen VII antibodies) and a neutrophil-rich inflammatory infiltrate (close association to ACLE/SLE).


9.2.3 Subacute Cutaneous LE (SCLE)


The SCLE presents clinically with widespread annular, gyrated, and/or plaque-like erythrosquamous lesions in sun-exposed skin areas including décolleté and extensor sides of the arms, while the face typically is not involved. The majority of SCLE patients are ANA-positive. Among the ANA, anti-SSA/Ro and anti-SSB/La antibodies are the most characteristic antibodies for this CLE subset. These antibodies not only are important diagnostic markers but also have a functional impact, since newborn babies of anti-SSA/Ro-positive mothers have an increased risk to develop SCLE-like skin lesions which diminish with the decline of the maternal postpartal immunoglobulin protection. From a histological point of view, SCLE shows a cell-poor interface dermatitis with vacuolar degeneration of the basal epidermal layer, colloid bodies, immigration of skin-homing lymphocytes, and dermal mucin deposits [6, 7].


9.2.4 LE Tumidus (LET)


LET clinically presents with infiltrated erythematous maculae and plaques without epidermal scaling which primarily appear in sun-exposed skin areas including the face. LET shows a dynamic which is between subacute CLE and chronic CLE and therefore was classified as “intermediate CLE type” in the Düsseldorf classification of CLE [1]. Histologically, the lesions are characterized by an extensive dermal spot-like perivascular and perifollicular inflammatory lymphoid infiltrate without any epidermal component. This inflammation is dominated by CD123-positive plasmacytoid dendritic cells, which form clusters of more than ten cells together. This inflammation is accompanied by strong dermal mucin deposits. Most of the patients are ANA-negative, and SLE-typical organ manifestations are uncommon in LET. Particularly, anti-SSA/Ro and SSB/La, which are frequently found in other photosensitive CLE subsets, are almost completely lacking [8, 9].


9.2.5 Chronic Discoid LE (CDLE)


The most common CLE subset is the chronic discoid LE (CDLE). It presents clinically with chronic, discoid, scarring, erythrosquamous plaques particularly affecting the capillitium and face. Most manifestations remain localized to one body region, but extensive courses with widespread scarring lesions appear in up to 10 % of the cases. In contrast to the extensive lesional skin damage, CDLE patients have only a minor risk to develop SLE, and the ANA titers are usually low. The most typical clinical sign of CDLE is the so-called tin-tack sign: a painful hyperkeratosis with follicular plugging due to the follicular hyperkeratosis of CDLE. Histologically, the lesions show a dense periadnexal and perivascular lymphoid inflammation, accompanied by a cell-rich interface dermatitis with a broadened basement membrane. Older lesions are characterized by fibrosis, due to the scarring character of this CLE subset [5].


9.2.6 LE Profundus (LEP)


In early stages, patients suffering from LEP show subcutaneous nodules and pad-like indurations of the dermis and subcutis. During the course of the disease, the patients develop lipoatrophy with retractions of the skin. The gluteal region is the predilection site of the disease, but the thighs, upper arms, and the face may also be involved. Histologically, LEP (also called “lupus panniculitis”) shows a lobular panniculitis with several CD8-positive cytotoxic T cells, accompanied by CD123-positive plasmacytoid dendritic cells and lesional expression of type I IFN-regulated cytokines. CLE-typical changes may also be seen in the dermis (e.g., mucin depositions) and at the dermoepidermal junction (interface dermatitis) in individual cases [1012].

May 5, 2016 | Posted by in Dermatology | Comments Off on Acknowledging the Clinical Heterogeneity of Lupus Erythematosus

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access