Lasers are useful for treating a variety of dermatologic conditions but have a number of potential complications associated with their use.
A basic understanding of laser mechanics is paramount in preventing and troubleshooting complications.
Wavelength, fluence, pulse duration and spot size can be varied to achieve the desired effect on tissue.
The innovation of coupling surface cooling with laser treatment has allowed for the use of increased fluence to maximize treatment efficacy while minimizing damage to the overlying epidermis.
Complications can be avoided by keeping the operating room safe. This includes the use of eye protection and smoke evacuators, when indicated. Operating suites should have well marked signs and restricted entry. Lasers should be kept in standby mode when not in use.
Only adequately trained physicians should evaluate patients and determine their candidacy for laser treatment and select treatment parameters. This will help ensure that lasers are not being used inadequately to treat potentially hazardous indications such as skin cancers.
Patients that give a history of pigmentary disorders, connective tissue diseases or abnormal scarring are at increased risk of having an adverse event following laser therapy. Those on certain medications or with dark or tanned skin are also at increased risk.
Pain, erythema and edema, crusting and vesiculation, purpura, dyspigmentation and scarring are side effects caused by treatment with most dermatologic lasers to varying degrees. These side effects can be minimized or avoided entirely when proper precautions are taken.
Other side effects are unique to treatment of specific conditions. For example, tattoo removal can be associated with allergic contact dermatitis or paradoxical tattoo darkening, while resurfacing procedures pose an increased risk of infection.
Introduction
Dermatologic laser therapy was initially introduced in the 1960s; however, it was not until the theory of selective photothermolysis was introduced that their use became widespread. There are a variety of side effects and complications associated with laser therapy. Some of these are unavoidable but many are preventable. Understanding laser mechanics and how to vary wavelength, fluence, pulse duration and spot size to achieve the desired effect can help minimize or prevent adverse events. Cooling has allowed for the use of increased fluence to maximize treatment efficacy by protecting the epidermis from excess thermal damage. |
Since the introduction of lasers into the dermatologic field by Dr. Leon Goldman in 1963,1 they have become both standard treatment for many dermatoses and a source of future innovations. While generally considered safe and well tolerated, their potential to cause adverse events should not be underestimated. A thorough understanding of lasers and their applications is paramount in managing predictable side effects and avoiding complications. This chapter will briefly outline laser mechanics, provide a detailed description of both common and uncommon complications, and discuss their prevention and treatment.
Laser Mechanics
The word laser is an acronym for light amplification by the stimulated emission of radiation.2 Laser light is unique in that it is composed of a single wavelength and all emitted photons are in the same phase. These properties are termed monochromatic and coherent, respectively. The wavelength of light is determined by the optical medium, which can be a solid (e.g., alexandrite), liquid (e.g., pulsed dye laser) or gas (e.g., carbon dioxide laser). When laser light hits the skin, it is absorbed, reflected, transmitted, or scattered. The desired treatment effect occurs when the light is absorbed and the energy is converted to heat (photothermal), acoustic waves (photomechanical) or used in chemical reactions (photochemical). The majority of dermatologic lasers employ photothermal reactions.
In 1983, the theory of selective photothermolysis was introduced, revolutionizing the application of lasers.3 This theory posits that because each chromophore has a unique photoabsorption spectrum, it can be selectively targeted and destroyed using specific wavelengths. Endogenous chromophores include melanin, hemoglobin and water.2 Tattoo ink is an exogenous chromophore frequently targeted with laser therapy.
A basic understanding of laser physics is required to troubleshoot complications and difficult-to-treat patients. By varying wavelength, fluence, pulse duration and spot size, the desired effect can be achieved (see Table 1 for definitions). The wavelength of light used determines which tissue chromophores will be targeted. The energy per area emitted by the laser is the fluence. High fluence can result in untoward damage to tissue, while insufficient fluence will lead to incomplete treatment. The concept of pulse duration is vital in minimizing damage to the surrounding tissue. The ideal pulse duration is generally the same4 or shorter2 than the thermal relaxation time (TRT) of the target. Immediately following photon absorption, the chromophore loses this newly absorbed energy in the form of heat. TRT is the time required for a chromophore to lose 50% of its heat to the surrounding tissue and is directly proportional to the square of its diameter. Thus, there is a positive relationship between pulse duration, TRT and diameter of the target. Destruction of targets with a small diameter, such as melanosomes, requires small pulse durations in order to limit damage to surrounding tissue. Those with a larger diameter, such as blood vessels, can be treated with longer pulse durations. For this reason, Quality– or Q-switched (QS) lasers (see Table 1 for definitions) are often used for pigmented lesions, while pulsed dye lasers (PDL), with pulse durations in the millisecond range, are used for vascular lesions.
Table 1
Common laser definitions
Term | Definition | Unit of measurement |
---|---|---|
Fluence | Energy delivered per unit area | J/cm2 |
Pulse duration (pulse length or pulse width) Q-switched Long-pulsed | The time it takes a waveform to reach 50% of its full amplitude Q-switch is an optical valve in a laser that allows for rapid energy build-up before it is open to allow light out | 10-9–10-12 s 10-3 s |
Thermal relaxation time (TRT) | Time required for a target to lose 50% of its heat to the surrounding environment TRT µ (directly) target diameter2 | s |
Spot size | The diameter of the opening through which the laser beam is emitted | cm |
Spot size and wavelength can each impact the depth of penetration of the laser. Depth of penetration is determined by both the amount of light absorption in the tissue and the scatter.2 In general, larger spot sizes (10–15 mm) and longer wavelengths (1,000–1,200 nm) have less scatter than smaller spot sizes (3–5 mm) and shorter wavelengths (300–400 nm) and penetrate deeper into the tissue. However, when wavelengths exceed approximately 1,300 nm, such as the CO2 resurfacing laser at 10,600 nm, depth is limited to the superficial epidermis due to absorption by water, the primary targeted chromophore in this range.
Cooling
The ideal laser settings will provide enough thermal energy and selectivity to damage the targeted chromophore while minimizing injury to the surrounding skin.5 However, the energy required to damage the target often exceeds that which is needed to harm the overlying epidermis. In order to overcome this obstacle, cooling devices have been implemented. Many laser handpieces are now equipped with cryogen spray cooling or sapphire contact plates that cool the skin immediately prior to the laser pulse. The epidermis is then selectively cooled, raising the threshold for thermal damage, while temperatures for the intended (deeper) dermal targets are relatively unaffected. Pre-cooling with ice-packs, gel and aluminum rollers can also be used but these are generally not as effective as the incorporated cooling devices. In addition to increasing the treatment efficacy of lasers, cooling also plays a prominent role in providing anesthesia during therapy.
General Considerations
Safety in the operating suites, professional errors and certain patient factors should be initially considered to help limit adverse events. The operating suites should have well marked signs and restricted access, and lasers should be kept in standby mode when not in use. Use of eye protection and smoke evacuators should be employed when indicated. An appropriately trained physician should evaluate all patients to determine candidacy prior to laser treatment. This will limit improper laser treatment of various diseases, such as skin cancers. Laser parameters should also be set by the clinician. Patients with a history of pigmentary disorders, connective tissue disease or abnormal scarring may be at increased risk for laser treatment. Additionally, those with dark or tanned skin or taking certain medications may suffer from additional side effects. |
Safety in the Operating Rooms
Lasers are useful medical devices but can be dangerous. The operating staff and patient are susceptible to a number of hazards, including burns, accidental fires, infection and ocular injury. General safety measures, such as a visible door sign when the laser is in use and controlled access into the laser areas, are important. All lasers should be kept in standby mode when not in use and have a rapid deactivation mode to prevent unintentional firing. To avoid accidental fires, the use of oxygen and alcohol-based cleansing methods should be minimized. Each laser should have its own outlet, limiting the use of extension cords. Since human papilloma virus (HPV)6 and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)7 particles have been found in aerosolized material after laser therapy, a smoke evacuator should be employed when lasers with significant potential to splatter aerosolized particles (such as CO2 resurfacing) are used.
Lasers can subject the unprotected eye to significant damage, including visual loss. The degree of ocular damage is determined by the wavelength of light as well as the amount and duration of energy exposure.8 Within the eye, there is a broad absorption spectrum resulting from three primary chromophores: melanosomes, found in the retinal epithelium, iris, sclera and choroid; hemoglobin, found in retinal vasculature; and water, found primarily in the cornea and lens. The symptoms associated with damage to these ocular structures are summarized in Table 2. Especially important to remember is that absorption of light outside the visual spectrum is visually undetectable. Additionally, due to their lack of sensory innervation, absorption damage to the retina, iris, choroid and sclera can be painless. Thus, ocular exposure to wavelengths in the near infrared range (700–1,400 nm), which is primarily absorbed by these pigmented eye structures, can lead to pronounced injury without symptoms.8,10
Wavelength (nm) | Susceptible ocular structure | Chromophore | Mechanism | Associated symptoms |
---|---|---|---|---|
180–400 | Cornea and lens | Tissue proteins | Photochemical | Pain |
400–700 | Retina, iris, choroid, sclera | Melanin | Photothermal | Color flash and afterimage |
700–1,400 | As above | As above | As above | No symptoms until significant visual loss |
1,400–10,600 | Cornea and lens | Water | As above | Immediate burning pain |
To prevent untoward injury, wavelength-specific eye protection should be worn any time the laser is in operation. Metal contact lenses should be placed on the patient when treating periorbital skin, and metal goggles should be worn for the treatment of facial lesions. Plastic goggles should be avoided in these cases due to the risk of melting. Pediatric and smaller patients should have size-specific goggles; if these are not available, the use of a thick layer of white gauze (which non-specifically absorbs and reflects laser light) can be used.
Professional Errors
An appropriately trained physician should evaluate all patients prior to laser treatment to determine whether they will be appropriate candidates for therapy. Some patients are at increased risk of sustaining complications (see Patient Factors section below), and these factors should be considered prior to choosing laser parameters. In some cases these risk factors may prove to be contraindications to laser treatment, as the risk of complications may outweigh the benefits. Verbal and written informed consent, including an explanation of the potential risks and benefits, alternative treatment options, number of treatment sessions, and cost per session should be obtained prior to the planned procedure which can help avoid the patient feeling pressured into making a quick decision.11
The indication for laser therapy must be appropriate. While treatment of rhytides may seem straightforward, treatment of other lesions, such as those on photo-damaged skin, may present more challenges to the non-dermatologist. Often, only minor differences distinguish a solar lentigo from a melanoma, or an actinic keratosis from a nonmelanoma skin cancer. These subtleties may not be obvious to the untrained clinician. Any lesion in question should be biopsied prior to treatment.
Troubleshooting complications requires a firm understanding of laser mechanics. A skilled operator will not only choose appropriate laser settings, but will be attentive in monitoring the tissue reaction to the laser treatment. An immediate white/gray discoloration can indicate significant thermal damage requiring modification of laser settings. Ideally, test spots should be done at least 2 weeks prior to the planned procedure.
Patient Factors
Patient factors must be taken into account in the assessment of an individual’s risk profiles. Patients with dark or tanned skin are at increased risk of hypopigmentation if treated with lasers that target melanosomes. Any history of abnormal scarring, vasculopathy or vitiligo should be elicited, as these conditions may indicate a propensity toward hypertrophic scarring, bruising and dyspigmentation, respectively. Treatment should be avoided in areas with concurrent infection or inflammation as it can exacerbate these conditions. Connective tissue diseases, which can be a marker for photosensitivity, may be a contraindication to laser therapy.12 One study reported new-onset discoid lupus erythematosus thought to be from thermal injury sustained after argon laser treatment for facial telangiectases.13 Debate exists in the literature, however, as others have successfully treated discoid lupus with similar lasers.14 Additionally, there are several medications (summarized in Table 3) that may confer an increased risk of complications. These should be considered and avoided if possible.15,16,19,20
Table 3
Medications potentially associated with increased risk of laser therapy complications
Medication | Possible associated complications | Recommendations |
---|---|---|
Blood thinning agents: Aspirin Coumadin Vitamin E Anti-platelet agents | Increased bruising, bleeding | Consider discontinuation if using laser with high bruising potential (e.g., PDL) |
Indomethacin | Increased scarring potential shown in murine models15 | Not good evidence for discontinuation, but may consider if high risk of scarring |
Isotretinoin | Consider discontinuation 6 months prior, especially if using lasers with high scarring potential (e.g., ablative resurfacing)19; evidence for this, however, is weak | |
Drugs that induce pigmentation: Minocycline Amiodarone Anti-malarials Tricyclic anti-depressants (e.g., desipramine, imipramine) | Dyspigmentation | Consider discontinuation prior to procedure if there is increased risk of dyspigmentation (e.g., dark or tanned skin, ablative resurfacing procedures) |
Gold (parenteral) | Localized chrysiasis after QS laser treatment20 | Consider avoiding treatment in patients with history of parenteral gold therapy |
General Laser Complications
Dermatologic lasers share a number of side effects that can be minimized or avoided when proper precautions are taken. Wavelength, fluence, pulse duration, spot size and cooling can all impact the degree of side effects experienced. Overlapping pulses and high fluences may help achieve a desired affect, but can increase the risk of complications. In general, ablative resurfacing procedures have an increased incidence of these complications compared with other laser modalities. |
Lasers can be used to treat a wide variety of conditions and each laser has its own unique properties (Table 4). A complication, or adverse event, can be defined as any undesirable or unforeseen outcome after a particular treatment. This is to be distinguished from a side effect, which is expected after therapy. However, many side effects, if severe, can lead to complications.
Table 4
Commonly used lasers listed by indication
Vascular lesions | Pigmented lesions | Tattoo removal | Photoepilation | Resurfacing |
---|---|---|---|---|
PDL (585–600 nm) | QS Ruby (694 nm) | QS Ruby (694 nm) | LP Ruby (694 nm) | Carbon dioxide (10,600 nm) |
LP Nd:YAG (1,064 nm) | QS Nd:YAG (532, 1,064 nm) | QS Nd:YAG (532, 1,064 nm) | LP Nd:YAG (1,064 nm) | Er:YAG (2,490 nm) |
LP KTP (532 nm) | QS Alexandrite (755 nm) | QS Alexandrite (755 nm) | LP Alexandrite (755 nm) | Fractional (1540 nm) |
IPL | IPL | LP Diode (800 nm) | ||
IPL | IPL |
The most common complications, which can occur with any laser, are pain, erythema and edema, crusting and vesiculation, purpura, dyspigmentation and scarring. Identifying the causative factor for each of these common complications can aid in their prevention and treatment. It is important to ask the following:
Am I treating the correct indication and patient with the correct laser?
Was the fluence appropriate?
Was the pulse duration appropriate?
Was the correct spot size used?
Was the cooling appropriate?
Was there too much pulse overlap or stacking of passes?
The purpose of this section will be to review each of these common side effects and discuss their prevention and management.
Pain
Risk Factors for Excess Pain
Inadequate anesthesia
High fluence
Insufficient cooling
Although certain lasers are associated with more pain than others, some level of mild pain is an expected side effect of most laser therapy. Unexpected or excessive pain, however, can occur with inadequate anesthesia or inappropriate laser settings (excess fluence or insufficient cooling).
Prevention and Treatment
It is imperative to appropriately anesthetize patients, as needed, prior to their procedure. Some lasers (e.g., the PDL) often do not require pre-treatment anesthesia, while use of other lasers (e.g., resurfacing lasers) require significant pain control. Anesthetics can be injected subcutaneously to provide local relief, whereas regional nerve blocks can provide anesthesia over a larger area. For those patients unable to tolerate the pain from injection of local anesthetic, pre-cooling with aluminum rollers or ice-packs for several minutes or application of topical anesthetic compounds 1 h prior to needle insertion can minimize their discomfort. Pretreatment with Er:YAG pulses followed by topical lidocaine may minimize needle insertion pain even further.21
Anesthesia may also be achieved with only topical treatment. A randomized, placebo controlled trial with 30 patients found topical lidocaine/tetracaine (S-Caine) peels successful in adequately relieving pain associated with tattoo removal.22 A set protocol with hot compresses, topical lidocaine and oral anxiolytics (vicodin, diazepam or ketorolac) provided adequate pain relief in 190 of 200 patients who underwent CO2 resurfacing in a recent case series.23 The disadvantage of using topical treatments, however, is the additional time required for the anesthetic to take effect.
Cooling devices have played a large role in minimizing pain and optimizing treatment of specific lesions. Decreased pain was associated with concomitant cooling in both the treatment of port-wine stains with the PDL24 and pigmented lesions with the QS Alexandrite.25 Pre-cooling (e.g., with aluminum rollers or ice packs) may also significantly reduce pain.26
Erythema and Edema
Risk Factors for Excess Erythema and Edema
Pulse stacking, multiple passes
High energy settings
Location (periocular > other areas)
Patient factors (fair skin > dark skin; history of acne rosacea)
Use of topical tretinoin prior to procedure
Inadequate post-treatment cooling
Erythema and edema are expected side effects of most laser therapies. Although these are usually transient, they can persist for months. A retrospective study of 500 patients who underwent CO2 laser resurfacing found that all patients experienced post-operative erythema lasting an average of 4.5 months.27 Prolonged erythema and edema occurs in preventable situations. Excess pulse stacking or passes,28 treatment of periocular areas, and use of high energy settings can all lead to prolonged erythema and edema. Additionally, patients with fair skin or a history of acne rosacea may be predisposed to intense erythema. Use of irritating medications, such as topical tretinoin, may also worsen erythema.29
Prevention and Treatment
If possible, unnecessary risks should be avoided. However, treatment efficacy is often maximized with pulse stacking and use of high-energy settings. Ensuring the patient is aware of these risks and that their expectations are appropriate cannot be overemphasized. Management of erythema and edema is supportive: application of post-treatment cold-packs, head elevation and sun precautions are important. Topical or oral corticosteroids can be used in severe cases. Topical ascorbic acid may be effective in decreasing the post-operative severity and duration of erythema after ablative resurfacing procedures.30
Crusting and Vesiculation
Risk Factors for Excess Crusting and Vesiculation
High fluence
Insufficient cooling
Small spot size
Short wavelengths
Crusting and vesiculation are manifestations of epidermal damage that generally results from excess thermal injury. This is commonly due to high fluence and/or insufficient cooling. Additionally, treatment with small spot sizes and shorter wavelengths imparts a higher risk of epidermal damage due to shallower depth of penetration. It is important to keep in mind, however, that some superficial crusting is an expected side effect for many lasers.
Prevention and Treatment
Treatment is supportive. Keeping wounds moist with petrolatum may help speed the recovery process and minimize the risk of scarring. Use of over-the-counter antibiotic ointments should be avoided as neomycin and bacitracin are some of the most common causes of allergic contact dermatitis31 and bacitracin has shown no wound healing benefit over white petrolatum.32 Sun precautions are recommended. Patients should be instructed not to unroof blisters, if they form. Symptomatic bullae can be lanced in a sterile fashion.
Purpura
Risk Factors for Excess Purpura
High fluence
Long wavelengths
Treatment with pulsed dye lasers (purpura mode)
Purpura results when there is damage to small vessels and subsequent extravasation of red blood cells. It is common following treatment with the PDL and is, in fact, a therapeutic endpoint when treating certain vascular lesions with short pulse durations and high fluences (so-called purpura-mode). Nevertheless, unexpected bruising can occur with use of other lasers if the fluence is set too high. Lasers with long wavelengths penetrate deeper and have a greater risk of damaging dermal blood vessels. Cooling, which primarily protects the epidermis, has little impact on the amount of damage to dermal blood vessels.
Prevention and Treatment
If possible, all patients should be off anti-coagulant and anti-platelet agents at least several days prior to the planned procedure. Discontinuing a medication, even if transiently, should always be discussed with the patient’s prescribing physician first.
Lowering fluence and increasing pulse duration (in the PDL) can help minimize purpura.
Because many vascular lesions, such as port wine stains and hemangiomas, cannot be effectively treated with non-purpuric parameters, patients should be aware of the potential down-time post-treatment. This is particularly important for people with high cosmetic demands. In one study, 45% of patients with purpura after treatment of their port-wine stains reported significant restriction in activity, primarily due to the bruising.33